Forged vs Hypereutectic Pistons???
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: Carrollton, TX, USA
Posts: 779
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Car: 1992 Chevy Camaro RS
Engine: 305 TBI
Transmission: T-56
Forged vs Hypereutectic Pistons???
Keith Black Hypereutectic 383 Pistons (Part Number KB-100) - $24.65 each
SRP Forged 383 Pistons - $56.63 each
TRW Forged 383 Flat Top 2VR Pistons - $41.00 each
Going on a 383 Superram Daily Driver car.....with a max of 150HP shot of nitrous. I was orginally going to go with the SRP pistons...but read this in a book.
"one advantage of the cast piston over the forged piston is that it requires less piston to bore clearance and in a high performance street engine, for instance, this will mean quieter operation, better ring seal (less piston rock) and frequently more power beacuse of it. High-performance street engines work from idle through to 5500 rpm much more than they do from 5500rpm to 6500rpm. If an engine is not going to be constantly turning high rpm cast pistons are the better option. "
Its an old book, so maybe pistons now a days are different....which is what I wanted to find out. I thought hyper pistons would be a good middle ground.....but if what is said above is not really true, or not true anymore, or not something to worry about...I'll get the forged pistons...probably go ahead and get the SRPs instead of TRW. Any input please.
SRP Forged 383 Pistons - $56.63 each
TRW Forged 383 Flat Top 2VR Pistons - $41.00 each
Going on a 383 Superram Daily Driver car.....with a max of 150HP shot of nitrous. I was orginally going to go with the SRP pistons...but read this in a book.
"one advantage of the cast piston over the forged piston is that it requires less piston to bore clearance and in a high performance street engine, for instance, this will mean quieter operation, better ring seal (less piston rock) and frequently more power beacuse of it. High-performance street engines work from idle through to 5500 rpm much more than they do from 5500rpm to 6500rpm. If an engine is not going to be constantly turning high rpm cast pistons are the better option. "
Its an old book, so maybe pistons now a days are different....which is what I wanted to find out. I thought hyper pistons would be a good middle ground.....but if what is said above is not really true, or not true anymore, or not something to worry about...I'll get the forged pistons...probably go ahead and get the SRPs instead of TRW. Any input please.
#3
Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: Carrollton, TX, USA
Posts: 779
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Car: 1992 Chevy Camaro RS
Engine: 305 TBI
Transmission: T-56
what about the whole piston to bore clearance blah blah. Just ignore it and go with the forged? Definetly the max rpm i'll be hitting is 6500 rpm.
#4
Supreme Member
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: USA
Posts: 4,969
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Car: yy wife, crazy.
Engine: 350, Vortecs, 650DP
Transmission: TH-350
Axle/Gears: 8.5", 3.42
Hypereutectic pistons are fine for 150HP shot of the juice.
Forged pistons are only needed for a 450+HP motor, plus a 250HP shot of nitrous.
The term hypereutectic means that the casting of the piston has a higher level of silicon in it.
What we call a regular cast piston is a eutectic. The 'hyper' part just means there's more than 11% of silicon in the piston.
By using higher amounts of silicon in the casting, the piston has better thermal characteristics than that of a regular cast piston. IE, it's more resistant to melting from heat. Kinda like a forged piston.
A forged piston is just that, it's heated to a very high temp after it is cast. This causes the aluminum to become very hard. They have the highest level of heat resistance. That's due to there expanding ability.
Because of there ability to expand, you must allow more clearance so they don't seize themselves to the cylinder walls as they heat up and get bigger. And they usually require more ring gap because of how small they become when they cool. Otherwise the ends of the rings would be touching at start-up, and that would be very very bad.
The piston rock is caused at start-up from the pistons being smaller, and having more room to move. Once the pistons warm up, and swell, then the clearance is smaller, and they sit tighter in the cylinders.
I think hypereutectic pistons got a bad name for the same reason that EFI did when it first came out.
A bunch of beer drinkin' old timers were sitting around sayin' "Why can't they just leave stuff alone? All this new stuff is confusing us. If it's confusing us, then it must be bad. So let's tell everyone how bad the new stuff is."
AJ
Forged pistons are only needed for a 450+HP motor, plus a 250HP shot of nitrous.
The term hypereutectic means that the casting of the piston has a higher level of silicon in it.
What we call a regular cast piston is a eutectic. The 'hyper' part just means there's more than 11% of silicon in the piston.
By using higher amounts of silicon in the casting, the piston has better thermal characteristics than that of a regular cast piston. IE, it's more resistant to melting from heat. Kinda like a forged piston.
A forged piston is just that, it's heated to a very high temp after it is cast. This causes the aluminum to become very hard. They have the highest level of heat resistance. That's due to there expanding ability.
Because of there ability to expand, you must allow more clearance so they don't seize themselves to the cylinder walls as they heat up and get bigger. And they usually require more ring gap because of how small they become when they cool. Otherwise the ends of the rings would be touching at start-up, and that would be very very bad.
The piston rock is caused at start-up from the pistons being smaller, and having more room to move. Once the pistons warm up, and swell, then the clearance is smaller, and they sit tighter in the cylinders.
I think hypereutectic pistons got a bad name for the same reason that EFI did when it first came out.
A bunch of beer drinkin' old timers were sitting around sayin' "Why can't they just leave stuff alone? All this new stuff is confusing us. If it's confusing us, then it must be bad. So let's tell everyone how bad the new stuff is."
AJ
Last edited by AJ_92RS; 02-20-2002 at 11:58 AM.
#5
Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: Carrollton, TX, USA
Posts: 779
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Car: 1992 Chevy Camaro RS
Engine: 305 TBI
Transmission: T-56
Originally posted by AJ_92RS
Hyperuetectic pistons are fine for 150HP shot of the juice.
Forged pistons are only needed for a 450+HP motor, plus a 250HP shot of nitrous.
Hyperuetectic pistons are fine for 150HP shot of the juice.
Forged pistons are only needed for a 450+HP motor, plus a 250HP shot of nitrous.
#6
Moderator
iTrader: (14)
Join Date: Mar 2000
Location: Littleton, CO USA
Posts: 43,169
Likes: 0
Received 35 Likes
on
34 Posts
Car: 82 Berlinetta/57 Bel Air
Engine: LS1/LQ4
Transmission: 4L60E/4L80E
Axle/Gears: 12B-3.73/9"-3.89
Originally posted by AJ_92RS
The term hyperuetectic means that the casting of the piston has a higher level of silicon in it.
What we call a regular cast piston is a eutectic. The 'hyper' part just means there's more than 11% of silicon in the piston.
The term hyperuetectic means that the casting of the piston has a higher level of silicon in it.
What we call a regular cast piston is a eutectic. The 'hyper' part just means there's more than 11% of silicon in the piston.
By using higher amounts of silicon in the casting, the piston has better thermal characteristics than that of a regular cast piston. IE, it's more resistant to melting from heat. Kinda like a forged piston.
FWIW, what we call "cast" and "hypereutectic" are both made with a casting process; the methods have to vary slightly to keep the hypereutectic material molten so it will flow properly into the mold.
A forged piston is just that, it's heated to a very high temp after it is cast. This causes the aluminum to become very hard.
Way off. They are made out of a different alloy entirely. The material is forced into shape without being molten, which induces grain flow, which is a big factor in making them stronger. Rough machining, stress relief, and final machining follow. Other processes may be involved, depending upon the design.
They have the highest level of heat resistance. That's due to there expanding ability.
They are stronger, due to the material and forging process, in the same way hypereutectics are (explained above).
Because of there ability to expand, you must allow more clearance so they don't seize themselves to the cylinder walls as they heat up and get bigger.
Close. Because they will withstand more heat, they must be allowed to expand more.
Enough for now...
Last edited by five7kid; 02-20-2002 at 12:07 PM.
#8
Forged definitely. I believe SpeedPro (I think) has a new forged piston out that does not expand as much with heat so it can be fitted to the bore tighter. Look in the Summit catalog. I believe thats where I read it. I have seen KB hypers last just fine in 500hp+ motors WITHOUT nitrous or supercharging. If you are going to do either of these I would definitely go forged.
#9
Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: Carrollton, TX, USA
Posts: 779
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Car: 1992 Chevy Camaro RS
Engine: 305 TBI
Transmission: T-56
Yeah I was wondering if there were any forged pistons that didnt expand as much. Not sure if they existed or not. I'll look at a few catalogs and see if i can find anything.
#10
Re: Forged vs Hypereutectic Pistons???
five7kid, excellent information! I think all the misnomers regarding Hyperuetectic vs forged pistons need to be revisited. I run KB Hyperuetectic pistons with a 100 shot of squeeze in a 400+ hp motor only and have not seen any unusual adverse affects. I'm not saying this is the very best scenario but on a buck to ET level I believe there a good choice. Some of us just don't have a John Force budget.
IMHO
Metalax
IMHO
Metalax
#11
Re: Forged vs Hypereutectic Pistons???
Where is AJ coming from? The rings don't butt together cold, that is the gap you have when you build the motor. The reason for larger ring gaps in todays schemes is that the extreme heat from nitrous will close the gap.
Forged pistons are more malible and absorb the shock of detonation that can happen easy with spray. Hyper pistons are strong and don't expand much, but they are brittle.
Short story
You want quite long lasting street car with minumum spray go hyper.
If your building a play car for a lot of strip abuse forged is the way go.
Forged pistons are more malible and absorb the shock of detonation that can happen easy with spray. Hyper pistons are strong and don't expand much, but they are brittle.
Short story
You want quite long lasting street car with minumum spray go hyper.
If your building a play car for a lot of strip abuse forged is the way go.
#13
Member
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Nova Scotia, Canada
Posts: 107
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Car: 87IROC/88GTA/02Sierra/04GrandPrix
Engine: 406 / 305 / 4.8 / 3.8
Transmission: T56 / T5 / 4L60e / ??
Axle/Gears: 3.70 / 3.45 / 3.42 / ??
Re: Forged vs Hypereutectic Pistons???
Holy crap old post! 2002! LOL
Use forged for any application using laughing gas. I can almost guarantee you'll lift the top ring land off the hypereutechtics after a number of decent length nitrous runs. The top ring will butt together and you'll have a piston that looks like the picture on the KB silvolite website under 'special clearance requirements'. If you push the limit on compression ratio I'd recommend the forged units, even without giggle juice.
Use forged for any application using laughing gas. I can almost guarantee you'll lift the top ring land off the hypereutechtics after a number of decent length nitrous runs. The top ring will butt together and you'll have a piston that looks like the picture on the KB silvolite website under 'special clearance requirements'. If you push the limit on compression ratio I'd recommend the forged units, even without giggle juice.
#14
Re: Forged vs Hypereutectic Pistons???
Yes all the aluminum or steel is cast/melted it could then be poured in to a mold for a cast product or poured in to ingots/blanks that are then forged into shape.
The following users liked this post:
northsidemechan (04-11-2024)
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
LT1Formula
Engine/Drivetrain/Suspension Parts for Sale
7
10-08-2015 08:34 PM
skinny z
Engine/Drivetrain/Suspension Parts for Sale
5
10-05-2015 06:23 PM
Dragonsys
Engine/Drivetrain/Suspension Parts for Sale
2
09-25-2015 03:51 PM
383, aluminum, cast, comparison, forged, hp, hyper, hypereutectic, hyperutectic, kb, limit, mean, nitrous, piston, pistons