Tech / General EngineIs your car making a strange sound or won't start? Thinking of adding power with a new combination? Need other technical information or engine specific advice? Don't see another board for your problem? Post it here!
Welcome to ThirdGen.org!
Welcome to ThirdGen.org.
You are currently viewing our forum as a guest, which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our community, at no cost, you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is free, fast and simple, join the ThirdGen.org community today!
I need to post pics of what my dads 350 vortec did at 6:00 pm tonight. Crank the engine over and CLANK, CLANK, CLANK, Starts running on 6 cylinders or so. Kill the engine immediately, look underneath. Oil is everywhere, coming from 4 small holes in the pan. Open the radiator cap and coolant pours out. Thats right connecting rod failure on an easy driven 57,000 mile 1997 350 vortec. It has had the oil religiously changed at 3,000 miles too. Now you know why I dislike 350s.
__________________ 1983 LE9 HO 9.2:1 305 4-bolt main
1405 600CFM edelbrock on Spectre 4 hole adapter
Late model TBI air cleaner assembly
Federal Mogul CS 1014R Cam
"601" HO Heads (Gasket Matched, Bowl Ported, Race Stainless 1.84 &1.50 Valves.)
Dual Exhaust, Modified Cast Iorn manifolds. 250 HP @ 4500 & 280 Ft/Lbs @ 2400 at the rear wheels.
32* total advance @ 3,000 rpm
15.3 @ 90.
Yeah...and I heard that 350s were supporting the Taliban rebels too...
What? Obviously the 350 is a well-designed engine... I would think that the intake gasket failed (notorious cheap *** GM gaskets) and coolant mixed with the oil, which killed the bearings.
This is a GM problem, not a 350 issue...or they wouldn't have been building them from the late 60's until 1999 (Tahoes/Vans)
__________________ Adam
-on hiatus- 88 GTA- 406/700R4, HSR, Pro 220cc alum heads-Griffin- Victor Jr. WP
-91 RS/Z28 - 350 TPI, T-5, 3.73 posi, DFI to 730 swap, SLP CAI/Full Exh, etc
A buddy of mine works at a GM dealership and he said that the vortec 350's are notorious for throwing rods. Why I dont know, but he said that there is always a truck or SUV in there getting a ew vortec motor put in. I also think that is one of the reason it is so easy to find a set of used vortec heads, because after these guys blow the motors they sell the heads.
The guy at my local GM dealership is a total retard, overfilled my truck's transmission doing a simple fluid change.
Therefore, guys at GM dealerships are retards. Your buddy works at a GM dealership, so...
Quote:
Originally posted by IROCaholic A buddy of mine works at a GM dealership and he said that the vortec 350's are notorious for throwing rods. Why I dont know, but he said that there is always a truck or SUV in there getting a ew vortec motor put in. I also think that is one of the reason it is so easy to find a set of used vortec heads, because after these guys blow the motors they sell the heads.
Have you looked at the part # on that crank? Before you do, and show yourself what a foolish thing you just said, I'll give you a clue about something: 85-back 305 & 350 cranks are the same casting!!! There's no difference except balancing. Same for the rods. I'm not sure about the later 1-piece cranks, but if I know manufacturing in general, they'll be just like th e85-back ones. In other words, that 350 has the same unreliable crank and rods as a 305 of the same year, by part number.
So how is it that a motor whose block has a 4" bore diameter is inferior to a motor that is otherwise identical except its bore diameter is 3.736"????
Please help us all to undertand how that extra quarter-inch of bore makes the 350 a poorer motor than its later designed scaled-back little stepbrother.
"It's better to merely be thought a fool than to open your mouth and remove all doubt".
- someone much older than me, and wise besides, which is something I lay no claim to
__________________ "So many Mustangs, so little time..."
theres 1000s (heck 100,000s) of SBCs running fine. the only variable in yours is... well you.
lol, we're all jumpin on your *** because well... you're calling what is possibly the most reliable mass produced V8 ever made, unreliable...
same basic design since the late 50s until present has been made... simply because it works well. i think you're better off finding where YOUR engine was foobared then you are just calling the whole design scrap.
Why do you guys waste your time with such easy pickings. This guy obviously has limited experience with these engines. Let him be. Anyone who's anyone knows what a dumb statement this is. Not trying to be fussy, just wish more people would move on to technical stuff. RB83 and MrDude, you guys are obviously very very experienced and smart, so why so mean. Share some of that technical knowledge. Yeah, and I know the flames are coming. So I guess i'll just duck for now. :lala:
Originally posted by CamaroMike Why do you guys waste your time with such easy pickings. This guy obviously has limited experience with these engines. Let him be. Anyone who's anyone knows what a dumb statement this is. Not trying to be fussy, just wish more people would move on to technical stuff. RB83 and MrDude, you guys are obviously very very experienced and smart, so why so mean. Share some of that technical knowledge. Yeah, and I know the flames are coming. So I guess i'll just duck for now. :lala:
everything i posted, i said with a smile
re-read it with a friendly chuckle and you'll see i wasnt being mean... i even explained why everyone else jumped on his butt.
Sorry, I just couldn't help it. This guy is too funny to pass up an opportunity for a little humor.
So, to keep it tech, I guess I'll just agree that 350s are all junk, especially the Vortec ones, which is of course what makes everyone in the world not want those and instead makes 305s the highly prized and sought-after motor, that you always see winning at the races and stuff.
__________________ "So many Mustangs, so little time..."
I often wonder if the "Hecho en Mexico" engines are the ones that fail the most often. These blocks are rumored to have very thin casting walls. So thin that .030 overbore has rumored to break through the cylinder walls.
I'm not saying that a 350 is a bad motor. I am just saying the 2 that I have had, had defects. Its funny how the 305s that we have had last much longer than the 350s. This is just my observation.
If 350 vortec short-blocks don't die early, why do you think there are so many vortec heads on Ebay all the time. The rod bearings failed, the rods broke, etc so they sell the heads.
It probably isn't a 350 specific problem. I think it was poor quality control. I know that the 305 and 350 share most of the same parts. The 350 rods and crank maybe the same casting but it will be more durable in the 305 because they are under less stress. Usually the 305s block is thicker too. Both are sound engines. I just think someone got lazy on these last 2. Both were manufactured after 1996. I have no complaints with my early 80s 305s. If the 350 had been built to 1980s quality I probably wouldn't be sitting with holes in my oil pan.
Limited experience??? You guys must be crazy. We have had 2 305s go a combined 1/2 million miles and are still going. Knocking on wood.
Instead of poking at the fact that I find 305s plentiful, cheap, economical to operate, particularly durable and more than adequate in the power department, help me figure out why this engine croaked so early. I am thinking that the intake gasket leaked. I didn't know that hydraulic lock would do this much damage. I thought at worst it might bend a rod or break a ring. That is why I am thinking that GM didn't torque the rod bolts tight enough. The pan is windowed right were the rods of cylinders 3 and 4 meet the crank. I think the #3 rod let go, further disproving the intake gasket theory. I guess the head gasket could have leaked. My dad told me it cranked over real slow one time, the made a huge bang, then it started and the clanking began. He shut it off immediately, but the pan already had holes in it and coolant was pouring out with the oil. That means the block is probably trash. Unless the piston came out of the bore and it had coolant above it. For simplicity let assume the block is internally windowed. If so the cam is probably damaged. I have a roller cam 350 TBI shortblock with 20,000 miles on it. Is it interchangeablly the same block as the vortec? If so I can stick the Lt1 roller cam(sitting in my garage) in it, vortec lifters and retainer spyder, add a new vortec timing chain(crank sprocket has a wheel for a crank position sensor), vortec timing cover, vortec heads, vortec intake, and the vortec accessories. Drop it into his van and he will be on the road again.
Originally posted by Fast305 I'm not saying that a 350 is a bad motor. I am just saying the 2 that I have had, had defects. Its funny how the 305s that we have had last much longer than the 350s. This is just my observation.
i stand by my orignal statement of user error on that one. i mean im not saying you're a bad user. I am just saying the 2 that you have had, had failed. Its funny how the 100,000 that we have had last much longer than yours. This is just my observation.
(same logic see my point? )
Quote:
Originally posted by Fast305 If 350 vortec short-blocks don't die early, why do you think there are so many vortec heads on Ebay all the time. The rod bearings failed, the rods broke, etc so they sell the heads.
no offence, but this is a Really REALLY stupid statement.
the reason that everyone is ga-ga over the vortec heads is price. new ones are still being made by GM, and the over-the-counter GM price is really low. several years ago, a popular performance mag let the general public know about how good these cheap heads were... since then people have gone nuts over them. guys like me can get the cheap from lots of places.. some like to toss them on ebay because there are a bunch of suckers out there that think $500+shipping on a set of vortecs is some kind of deal.
Quote:
Originally posted by Fast305 It probably isn't a 350 specific problem. I think it was poor quality control.
possibly, but highly doubtful. as far as engine assembly, GM is amoung the best.. its kinda hard to fug up a SBC really... tolerances are huge and the parts are way understressed. i still think somthing else went wrong.
what did he do before it misfired with a big bang? by anychance did he flood (hydro-lock) it?
Quote:
Originally posted by Fast305 The 350 rods and crank maybe the same casting but it will be more durable in the 305 because they are under less stress.
true. they dont make **** for power. so they dont stress them as much... then again a stock SBC 350 will go over 150,000 miles without issue... 200-300 if you take excelent care of it.
Quote:
Originally posted by Fast305 Usually the 305s block is thicker too.
nope
Quote:
Originally posted by Fast305 If the 350 had been built to 1980s quality I probably wouldn't be sitting with holes in my oil pan.
lmao.. if it was 80s quality, it would have smogger heads,tiny cam, and make 180hp...
of course 80s motors last forever... the damn things are so underpowered that they dont wear anything out but the valveseals.
and if they did blow, it really wouldnt have enough power to go thru the oil pan.. lol
Quote:
Originally posted by Fast305 Limited experience??? You guys must be crazy. We have had 2 305s go a combined 1/2 million miles and are still going. Knocking on wood.
i would def call that limited experience. i mean, you just quoted miles when we're talking about working on cars.
you could drive a billion miles, doesnt make you a mechanic.
Quote:
Originally posted by Fast305 Instead of poking at the fact that I find 305s plentiful, cheap, particularly durable and more than adequate in the power department, help me figure out why this engine croaked so early. I am thinking that the intake gasket leaked. My dad told me it cranked over real slow one time, the made a huge bang, then it started and the clanking began. He shut it off immediately, but the pan already had holes in it and coolant was pouring out with the oil. That means the block is probably trash. Unless the piston came out of the bore and it had coolant above it.
my guess... if the intake gasket leaked or possibly if it just got too much gas, it hydrolocked the motor, and the stress from that blew it apart.... then again, i didnt take it apart and look at it, so its a wild guess.
Quote:
Originally posted by Fast305 For simplicity let assume the block is internally windowed. I have a roller cam 350 TBI shortblock with 20,000 miles on it. Is it interchangeablly the same block as the vortec? If so I can stick the Lt1 roller cam(sitting in my garage) in it, vortec lifters and retainer spyder, add a new vortec timing chain(crank sprocket has a wheel for a crank position sensor), vortec timing cover, vortec heads, vortec intake, and the vortec accessories. Drop it into his van and he will be on the road again.
ok, down to the real responce..
yes its the same block. just be sure to have the correct flexplate/flywheel for the crank.. depending on if its one piece rear main or two. the top end will bolt right on.
i dont know what the compression will be though. might want to look into that.
other then that, yea that sounds like a workable plan. go for it.
As far as mechanic skills. I rebuilt the last 350 that died and it now has 50,000 miles on it. I rebuilt the 307 in my grandfathers 1988 cadillac(had 220,000 miles). It is still going strong. I cammed my 305 and rebuilt the heads. I am going to build this 350. I just rebuilt a 700r4 over my spring break. Before that I did a 3 spd stick. I have done several A/C rebuilds. Changed many engine accessories (numerous starters, alternators, compressors, P/S pumps, etc.). I have done carbs for many people including myself. I do work for other people all the time. What I meant by the 1/2 million mile mark, is that my dad has had experience in this and I have too. The failure was not because of the operator or lack of maintanence. I just rebuilt a mazda 2.0 for my little brothers mazda truck. Call me mechanics illiterate if you want, its your decision.
As far as the ebay thing. I have seen many used vortec heads on there. Many owners claiming other engine problems are the reason they are selling the heads.
You are right about 1980s engines being understressed. That makes them LAST FOREVER. You claim they are underpowered. They don't run 13-14 second quartermiles. So what. 180 HP is enough to move anything down the road, way over the speed limit.
I am glad to see this thread actually generated something useful. Luckily I can use the TBI shortblock and it will get the job done. I just looked up the compression. With 76 cc heads the HD 3/4 ton 350 tbi had 8.4:1 compression. If I use the vortec heads it will give me roughly 9.6:1 compression. Only 0.2:1 above the factory vortec.
Originally posted by RB83L69 ...
"It's better to merely be thought a fool than to open your mouth and remove all doubt".
- someone much older than me, and wise besides, which is something I lay no claim to ...
Either Abe Lincoln or Samuel L. Clemens. Seems to be some debate on that.
Fast 305, if you were stepping up and wanted to sell your old heads, would you say that in your sales pitch that you are using trying to convince someone to buy 'em? ex:
<b>These Vortecs suck for big power on big cubes! Please buy and subsidize my AFR's!!!</b>
See what I mean, really makes you want to buy 'em no?
It probably isn't a 350 specific problem. I think it was poor quality control. I know that the 305 and 350 share most of the same parts. The 350 rods and crank maybe the same casting but it will be more durable in the 305 because they are under less stress.
hold on a minute you tryin to say that a 305 is not under as much stress as a 350 man you got some learnin to do ...lol...how hard do people over rev a stock 305 to try and keep up with a 350 ..?????....LMAO
__________________ •"I work on my chevy because I want to ..I work on your ford because you pay me too"------THEGENERAL
•"If it's true that we are here to help others, then what exactly are the others here for?"-------George Carlin
•There's a place for all of gods creatures .....right next to the Potatoes & Gravy!
•R.I.P. Johnny Carson, 1925 - 2005 You will be missed.......
•"Never argue with an idiot, they'll just bring you down to their level and beat you with experience".....METALICAMARORS
I think what he means is that 305's arent under as much stress because they are the biggest dogs in the world. Unless, that is you have a 1980 smog 305. These are the fastest of the fast. THey also have walls so thick you can bore them .100. Best engines ever made. </sarcasm>
i think that the guy that started this thread was just lookin for someone to say no there is something wrong with this engine not with the way you drive..LMAO....and i dont think hes gonna get that here
__________________ •"I work on my chevy because I want to ..I work on your ford because you pay me too"------THEGENERAL
•"If it's true that we are here to help others, then what exactly are the others here for?"-------George Carlin
•There's a place for all of gods creatures .....right next to the Potatoes & Gravy!
•R.I.P. Johnny Carson, 1925 - 2005 You will be missed.......
•"Never argue with an idiot, they'll just bring you down to their level and beat you with experience".....METALICAMARORS
I think there is some truth to what he is saying about the vortec motors because I have seen them on Ebay saying the motor blew something on the bottom end so they are selling the heads, but my dad has a 350 TBI in a truck that has 195000 miles no problems except transmission, my GTA has 104000 miles no problems either, these are newer engines so there is bound to be a few problems
__________________ 2002 Trans Am WS6 LS1Ram Air
-15,000 Miles,C6 Wheels,Custom Chambered Exhaust(From Summit) 1999 Trans Am WS6 LS1(Wrecked)Ram Air
-Stock (2001 LS1Casting#12561584 with 241 Heads)
-Times:1/8=8.5801@83.66(13.15 1/4 mile estimated),2.0 60' 1983 CrossFire Trans Am WS7 305
-Hypertech Chip,Flowmaster 80 Series Muffler 1990 GTA Trans Am WS6 350(G92)
-Custom Chip,Throttle Body Bypass,Cold Air Intake,Car Sound Cats,3 inch Flowmaster Exhaust
-Times: (W/O Exhaust and Custom Tune By Mike(1bad91Z),Thanks)1/8=9.5380@72.49(14.67 1/4 mile estimated),2.1 60'