Third Generation F-Body Message Boards

Third Generation F-Body Message Boards (https://www.thirdgen.org/forums/)
-   TBI (https://www.thirdgen.org/forums/tbi/)
-   -   305 TBI developed a knock after idleing...... (https://www.thirdgen.org/forums/tbi/715085-305-tbi-developed-knock.html)

PATRIOTIC1911 02-14-2015 07:19 PM

305 TBI developed a knock after idleing......
 
So I have a 91 Firebird with the 305 TBI. The engine was rebuilt to factory specs about 6,000 miles ago. Last night while at my brothers, the car was idleing in the driveway for maybe 20 minutes engine temp was running 220. I something started knocking. Put a wood handle on my valve covers and everything internal there sounded fine. Once I drove home and the car cooled a bit, I started it and no knocking. Nothing throughout the day today either. I'm assuming, it was just running hot and something started knocking. I feel a lot better if I had ideas as to what it may have been. Engine sounded great all day today, though it never came near 220 temp either. Any ideas as to what it may have been?

cdjones85 02-14-2015 09:51 PM

Re: 305 TBI developed a knock after idleing......
 
3 Attachment(s)
It could have just been timing off for some reason. Running a low octane will cause a knock to develop. Ive even heard that a water pump going out can sound almost identical to a rod knock. I recently did a lot of knock investigation because the 91 Firebird 305 tbi i just got started knocking 3 days after i got it. I was hoping for something simple. The oil pressure was gone so i knew i was in trouble. I threw a rod out the bottom yesterday so now i am preparing for a 350 swap. I hope yours is not the same case as mine. If your oil pressure is still ok you are probably alright. good luck.

Schurkey 02-15-2015 02:39 AM

Re: 305 TBI developed a knock after idleing......
 

Originally Posted by cdjones85 (Post 5878182)
It could have just been timing off for some reason.

How does timing get "off"; and then heal itself later?

Originally Posted by cdjones85 (Post 5878182)
Running a low octane will cause a knock to develop.

At idle?

Originally Posted by cdjones85 (Post 5878182)
Ive even heard that a water pump going out can sound almost identical to a rod knock.

Do you mean "fuel pump"? Never heard a water pump knock; have heard plenty of engine-driven fuel pumps knock/tap.




I have seen/heard bearings knock/not knock/knock again. Take oil pressure readings with a trustworthy gauge.

PATRIOTIC1911 02-15-2015 02:46 AM

Re: 305 TBI developed a knock after idleing......
 
My oil pressure was fine and I run 91 octane only. I didn't hear anything all day today. It was weird. My brother and I were chatting next to the car. It had been idleing for a bit with the fan kicking on as it should. Then all of a sudden, we both start hearing this knock. The second it started, it stopped both of us in mid conversation. It was that noticeable. We just couldn't pin point it. It did seam to be more on the drivers side than the passenger side.
I live literally two minutes from him and in that time after driving, the temp of the car went down and i didn't hear it any more. Could it maybe have been exhaust manifold related or something?

PATRIOTIC1911 02-15-2015 09:42 AM

Re: 305 TBI developed a knock after idleing......
 

Originally Posted by Schurkey (Post 5878233)

I have seen/heard bearings knock/not knock/knock again. Take oil pressure readings with a trustworthy gauge.

Pulley bearings or something??

Schurkey 02-15-2015 12:57 PM

Re: 305 TBI developed a knock after idleing......
 

Originally Posted by PATRIOTIC1911 (Post 5878274)
Pulley bearings or something??

I was thinking spun main or rod bearings. Having spun, sometimes they overlap enough to take up clearance and the knock goes away--along with the oil pressure.

PATRIOTIC1911 02-15-2015 07:34 PM

Re: 305 TBI developed a knock after idleing......
 

Originally Posted by Schurkey (Post 5878338)
I was thinking spun main or rod bearings. Having spun, sometimes they overlap enough to take up clearance and the knock goes away--along with the oil pressure.

Wouldn't main or rod bearings continue to knock once they start? As far as my oil pressure gauge in the car, it's fine.

Schurkey 02-15-2015 11:21 PM

Re: 305 TBI developed a knock after idleing......
 

Originally Posted by PATRIOTIC1911 (Post 5878487)
Wouldn't main or rod bearings continue to knock once they start?

Usually. Not always. Sometimes it comes 'n' goes for awhile. It always gets worse over time--or the engine explodes.

Originally Posted by PATRIOTIC1911 (Post 5878487)
As far as my oil pressure gauge in the car, it's fine.

Unlikely to be crank bearings, then.

PATRIOTIC1911 02-16-2015 12:40 PM

Re: 305 TBI developed a knock after idleing......
 
I guess for now, I will just have to wait and listen to see if it does it again. This isn't a daily driver. Even in the non-winter months, I only get the car out a few times a month. I'll just pay attention to it and keep an eye and ear tuned. The car doesn't drip anything and doesn't burn oil one little bit. Thanks for what insight you all were able to give. Maybe it was just a fluke thing.......

mmadden55 02-16-2015 12:48 PM

Re: 305 TBI developed a knock after idleing......
 
Hot spotting from idling causing some detonation knock. antiknock sensor will generally pull some timing to stop that but at idle there isn't any to pull.

PATRIOTIC1911 02-16-2015 01:14 PM

Re: 305 TBI developed a knock after idleing......
 

Originally Posted by mmadden55 (Post 5878772)
Hot spotting from idling causing some detonation knock. antiknock sensor will generally pull some timing to stop that but at idle there isn't any to pull.

I've never heard the term "hot spotting" before. You up for explaining?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:34 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands