Third Generation F-Body Message Boards

Third Generation F-Body Message Boards (https://www.thirdgen.org/forums/)
-   Suspension and Chassis (https://www.thirdgen.org/forums/suspension-chassis/)
-   -   LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe? (https://www.thirdgen.org/forums/suspension-chassis/743793-lca-notched-machine-shop.html)

vilespankmachin 05-15-2017 11:15 AM

LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe?
 
Machine shop put these notches in my front LCA on the passenger side during bushing replacement. Both the front and rear bushings have notches. Drives side does not have this.

Are these going to be safe or will they crack along the notch? I think they'll be ok since the the metal collar on the bushing itself should distribute the load in the circular manner as it should, but I am not an engineer.

I did not ask the shop about it yet as I didn't notice until after I got home.

https://imgur.com/a/Nejup

Drew 05-15-2017 11:48 AM

Re: LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe?
 
If I paid for the labor, and they damaged my parts, I'd be pissed.

If I did that damage changing bushings myself, I'd fire up the welder just for peace of mind.

gt4373 05-15-2017 11:56 AM

Re: LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe?
 
Should Be Ok,But That Was A Lousy Uninstall By The Shop,Was No Need To Do That.

Bob88GTA 05-15-2017 12:09 PM

Re: LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe?
 
Good Job Machine shop! :thumbsup: I would go back....but no proof now. Get the welder out.

https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.thi...60a567a05a.jpg

paulo57509 05-15-2017 07:22 PM

Re: LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe?
 

Originally Posted by gt4373 (Post 6136676)
Should Be Ok,But That Was A Lousy Uninstall By The Shop,Was No Need To Do That.

That's what sometimes happens when someone uses a pneumatic hammer (with a chisel attachment) to remove the bushings.

TEDSgrad 05-15-2017 07:32 PM

Re: LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe?
 
You'll be OK. Just don't go back there.

I would have used Delrin bushings rather than rubber, but to each his own.

fullsize fun 05-15-2017 10:12 PM

Re: LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe?
 
looks like plasma cutter cuts....

83 Crossfire TA 05-17-2017 06:08 AM

Re: LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe?
 
Much like the rest, I'd be pissed that it happened and probably say something to the retarded monkey that did it, but when it comes down to it it won't likely hurt the control arm. If it was mine I'd probably put a small weld there.


Originally Posted by TEDSgrad (Post 6136801)
You'll be OK. Just don't go back there.

I would have used Delrin bushings rather than rubber, but to each his own.

Who makes Delrin bushings for these things? Delrin tends to be pretty hard, does it have enough give for the application?

TTOP350 05-17-2017 06:19 AM

Re: LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe?
 

Originally Posted by 83 Crossfire TA (Post 6137111)
Much like the rest, I'd be pissed that it happened and probably say something to the retarded monkey that did it, but when it comes down to it it won't likely hurt the control arm. If it was mine I'd probably put a small weld there.



Who makes Delrin bushings for these things? Delrin tends to be pretty hard, does it have enough give for the application?

Global West is where I got mine from a long time ago, Not sure If they still have them. EDIT: Yup, they still list em. http://www.globalwest.net/firebird-s...1991-1992.html

W.E.G. 05-17-2017 06:56 AM

Re: LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe?
 
For the DIY inclined


//<86TA>\\ 05-17-2017 10:46 AM

Re: LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe?
 
The global west bushings are for the front, not rear

Tibo 05-17-2017 12:51 PM

Re: LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe?
 

Originally Posted by vilespankmachin (Post 6136665)
Machine shop put these notches in my front LCA on the passenger side during bushing replacement. Both the front and rear bushings have notches. Drives side does not have this.

Are these going to be safe or will they crack along the notch? I think they'll be ok since the the metal collar on the bushing itself should distribute the load in the circular manner as it should, but I am not an engineer.

I did not ask the shop about it yet as I didn't notice until after I got home.

https://imgur.com/a/Nejup

Live and learn. For the cost of the new bushings and machine shop you wouldn't have been far behind for a set from Founders.

TEDSgrad 05-17-2017 02:01 PM

Re: LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe?
 

Originally Posted by 83 Crossfire TA (Post 6137111)
Who makes Delrin bushings for these things? Delrin tends to be pretty hard, does it have enough give for the application?

As mentioned, Global West has them. Still good folks.
The front control arms only rotate, so Delrin are perfect for the application.

TylerSteez 05-17-2017 07:08 PM

Re: LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe?
 
Send an email to the owner of the shop letting him know you're not impressed with the quality of his work.

vilespankmachin 05-17-2017 09:18 PM

Re: LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe?
 
[QUOTE=Tibo; Live and learn. For the cost of the new bushings and machine shop you wouldn't have been far behind for a set from Founders.[/QUOTE]

Is there an option for factory-style front LCAs? I did not see them.

I wanted to keep the factory stamped pieces as after a bit of research, they seemed to be the most durable option with the least NVH.

I normally do buy the new control arms with bushings and joints already installed because you are absolutely right, that is the way to go. I couldn't find a loaded stock style LCA for this application at any of my usual sources..

Thirdgen89GTA 05-17-2017 10:04 PM

Re: LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe?
 

Originally Posted by //<86TA>\\ (Post 6137150)
The global west bushings are for the front, not rear

Definitely don't want the Del-A-Lum bushings on the rear control arms.

The appeal of them is how smooth they are in rotation, with almost zero deflection.

But since the rear LCA's need to pivot as well as rotate up/down, the Del-A-Lum stuff would cause horrible binding.

83 Crossfire TA 05-18-2017 05:44 AM

Re: LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe?
 

Originally Posted by //<86TA>\\ (Post 6137150)
The global west bushings are for the front, not rear


Originally Posted by Thirdgen89GTA (Post 6137312)
Definitely don't want the Del-A-Lum bushings on the rear control arms.

The appeal of them is how smooth they are in rotation, with almost zero deflection.

But since the rear LCA's need to pivot as well as rotate up/down, the Del-A-Lum stuff would cause horrible binding.


Originally Posted by TEDSgrad (Post 6137193)
As mentioned, Global West has them. Still good folks.
The front control arms only rotate, so Delrin are perfect for the application.

I see that the first 2 quotes did the same as I did... if you click on the link and look at the pic it looks like it's a rear control arm, I didn't even think to scroll down and look at the second pic that shows it's a front one.

TEDSgrad, I knew about the del-a-lum bushings... I thought someone finally took the time and figured out what parts you need to just put these together from commodity supplies- delrin/nylon bushings are standard industrial stuff that are available for a few $ each, you'd just have to figure out how to fit them to the arms.

Honestly, since they do only rotate I don't know that I see a big advantage over some hard poly bushings, and by the time you get the GW bushings, ball joints and install them you can just about have a set of aftermarket control arms that are lighter and prettier ;)


Originally Posted by W.E.G. (Post 6137117)

I bet that setup costs more than a set of new control arms with bushings, but it should give some idea of how to make a home built bushing press...

TTOP350 05-18-2017 07:16 AM

Re: LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe?
 

Originally Posted by 83 Crossfire TA (Post 6137344)
I see that the first 2 quotes did the same as I did... if you click on the link and look at the pic it looks like it's a rear control arm, I didn't even think to scroll down and look at the second pic that shows it's a front one.

TEDSgrad, I knew about the del-a-lum bushings... I thought someone finally took the time and figured out what parts you need to just put these together from commodity supplies- delrin/nylon bushings are standard industrial stuff that are available for a few $ each, you'd just have to figure out how to fit them to the arms.

Honestly, since they do only rotate I don't know that I see a big advantage over some hard poly bushings, and by the time you get the GW bushings, ball joints and install them you can just about have a set of aftermarket control arms that are lighter and prettier ;)



I bet that setup costs more than a set of new control arms with bushings, but it should give some idea of how to make a home built bushing press...

I have removed poly from all my cars long ago, hated the bind and squeak. Not to mention they get hard, crack, shrink and fall out of their metal sleeves. I had put them in in the early 90s and had them back out a couple yrs after that.

83 Crossfire TA 05-23-2017 03:58 PM

Re: LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe?
 

Originally Posted by TTOP350 (Post 6137355)
I have removed poly from all my cars long ago, hated the bind and squeak. Not to mention they get hard, crack, shrink and fall out of their metal sleeves. I had put them in in the early 90s and had them back out a couple yrs after that.

I had poly Energy Suspension ones in my '83 that I installed around '92, no binding or squeaking there if installed with the grease. I took those out in the late 2000's (when I parted the car) and they were still in perfect shape. All the poly bushings I've installed since then I drilled for grease fittings. I won't use them anyplace where they'll be twisted against their axis, but otherwise they work fine if good quality.

t/aws61985 05-23-2017 04:31 PM

Re: LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe?
 
I would have just bought some UMI Panhard/LCA package. I never want to deal with removing bushings. Only like 170 shipped. I would be pissed with that work.

TTOP350 05-24-2017 06:25 AM

Re: LCA Notched By Machine Shop during Bushing Replacement - Safe?
 

Originally Posted by 83 Crossfire TA (Post 6138862)
I had poly Energy Suspension ones in my '83 that I installed around '92, no binding or squeaking there if installed with the grease. I took those out in the late 2000's (when I parted the car) and they were still in perfect shape. All the poly bushings I've installed since then I drilled for grease fittings. I won't use them anyplace where they'll be twisted against their axis, but otherwise they work fine if good quality.

I used their grease and tried other types as well. Got tired of it and just Kicked poly out.;)


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:25 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands