Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
#151
Supreme Member
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Hurst, Texas
Posts: 9,994
Received 386 Likes
on
329 Posts
Car: 1983 G20 Chevy
Engine: 305 TPI
Transmission: 4L60
Axle/Gears: 14 bolt with 3.07 gears
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Flash stall is about 2,500-2,800 rpm behind a 350 depending on how much torque your setup makes. Behind a stock 4.3 they stall about 2,200 rpm. In my heavy Express van it would stall about 2,800 rpm. In the Firebird it could only be brake stalled to 1,800 rpm at light throttle. Above 1,800 rpm the tires start spinning. Hammering the throttle from a stop resulted in spin city so it is hard to tell the exact rpm it stalls. The 4.3 converter does have a lockup clutch.
#152
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Flash stall is about 2,500-2,800 rpm behind a 350 depending on how much torque your setup makes. Behind a stock 4.3 they stall about 2,200 rpm. In my heavy Express van it would stall about 2,800 rpm. In the Firebird it could only be brake stalled to 1,800 rpm at light throttle. Above 1,800 rpm the tires start spinning. Hammering the throttle from a stop resulted in spin city so it is hard to tell the exact rpm it stalls. The 4.3 converter does have a lockup clutch.
I assume it shares the same spline count etc as the TC on my 700r4?
What diameter is it?
Just seeing if there is a cheaper option than getting a high stall converter
Cheers
#153
Supreme Member
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Cheap is relative I suppose and I can't comment on the S10 converter working one way or the other except for anecdotal evidence posted here and there.
What I do know is the both myself and my racing friend have used the TCI 10" Street fighter converter. I'll say that I was happy with it's performance (and still am from a steet perspective) until my friend stepped up to a custom spec'd Yank 9.5" (all of the above with the lock-up function). He picked up about 2/10ths in the quarter mile and yet it still has all of the street manners the TCI possesed. While the flash stall is one thing, it's what the converter does during WOT and the shift that seems to make the difference. While I can say that I arguably flash to almost 4000 (as seen in the dyno video attached), I can only foot brake to about 2200 rpm. During the shift I'll drop to an RPM appropriate to the gearing. (6500 rpm shift point x 1.63 2nd gear ratio = 3987+/-). With the Yank, during WOT, at the shift, RPMs are never less than 5000 rpm despite the gearing indicating an RPM of 4000 or so. That's the function of a well designed converter and something that produces quicker ETs. At least in as much as I can tell.
Back to the cheap...swappng a transmission in these cars (or any car for that matter) is something I'd rather not participate in. That, to me, takes away from the cheap factor.
From this video, the test RPMs start at 3000 and at the hit you can see a distinct jump to 4000. While hardly conclusive (from an RPM perspective due to all of the other variables) that'll give you an idea of what you might expect out of the TCI 10" and a Vortec build such as your own.
By the way, the stall coverter is still one of the biggest improvements that I've ever made judging by the old "butt dyno". Yet still very streetable and highway friendly due to the lock-up.
By the way, check out those AFRs on the far right side gauge. 13.1-12.8 all the way. Sweet! That pull only produced 290 rwhp/290rwt yet pushed that 3750 chassis to 107 mph in the quarter. That's saying something.
What I do know is the both myself and my racing friend have used the TCI 10" Street fighter converter. I'll say that I was happy with it's performance (and still am from a steet perspective) until my friend stepped up to a custom spec'd Yank 9.5" (all of the above with the lock-up function). He picked up about 2/10ths in the quarter mile and yet it still has all of the street manners the TCI possesed. While the flash stall is one thing, it's what the converter does during WOT and the shift that seems to make the difference. While I can say that I arguably flash to almost 4000 (as seen in the dyno video attached), I can only foot brake to about 2200 rpm. During the shift I'll drop to an RPM appropriate to the gearing. (6500 rpm shift point x 1.63 2nd gear ratio = 3987+/-). With the Yank, during WOT, at the shift, RPMs are never less than 5000 rpm despite the gearing indicating an RPM of 4000 or so. That's the function of a well designed converter and something that produces quicker ETs. At least in as much as I can tell.
Back to the cheap...swappng a transmission in these cars (or any car for that matter) is something I'd rather not participate in. That, to me, takes away from the cheap factor.
From this video, the test RPMs start at 3000 and at the hit you can see a distinct jump to 4000. While hardly conclusive (from an RPM perspective due to all of the other variables) that'll give you an idea of what you might expect out of the TCI 10" and a Vortec build such as your own.
By the way, the stall coverter is still one of the biggest improvements that I've ever made judging by the old "butt dyno". Yet still very streetable and highway friendly due to the lock-up.
By the way, check out those AFRs on the far right side gauge. 13.1-12.8 all the way. Sweet! That pull only produced 290 rwhp/290rwt yet pushed that 3750 chassis to 107 mph in the quarter. That's saying something.
Last edited by skinny z; 12-19-2014 at 07:30 PM.
#154
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Its a tricky thing
Most of this stuff I have to import from the states at huge expense.
I am also looking to bring in a built up 700r4 as I have been told my 83 700r4 is unlikely to last the extra stress the vortec 350 will place upon it. I have trouble trusting local auto shops as US trans' are not that common here and I don't want to pay 3K+ for a trans build only to have it go belly up on me.
The TC is one expense that at the moment I prefer to shelve till all other concerns with the car are sorted. 99.9% of my driving is open road so the soft starts really wont matter until I have it ready for a little bit of motorsport (way down the track after paint, brakes, auto etc,
I am prepared to listen to arguments otherwise if you feel this is a mistake.
As always Kevin, I welcome your input
Cheers
Most of this stuff I have to import from the states at huge expense.
I am also looking to bring in a built up 700r4 as I have been told my 83 700r4 is unlikely to last the extra stress the vortec 350 will place upon it. I have trouble trusting local auto shops as US trans' are not that common here and I don't want to pay 3K+ for a trans build only to have it go belly up on me.
The TC is one expense that at the moment I prefer to shelve till all other concerns with the car are sorted. 99.9% of my driving is open road so the soft starts really wont matter until I have it ready for a little bit of motorsport (way down the track after paint, brakes, auto etc,
I am prepared to listen to arguments otherwise if you feel this is a mistake.
As always Kevin, I welcome your input
Cheers
#155
Supreme Member
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Hurst, Texas
Posts: 9,994
Received 386 Likes
on
329 Posts
Car: 1983 G20 Chevy
Engine: 305 TPI
Transmission: 4L60
Axle/Gears: 14 bolt with 3.07 gears
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Its a tricky thing
Most of this stuff I have to import from the states at huge expense.
I am also looking to bring in a built up 700r4 as I have been told my 83 700r4 is unlikely to last the extra stress the vortec 350 will place upon it. I have trouble trusting local auto shops as US trans' are not that common here and I don't want to pay 3K+ for a trans build only to have it go belly up on me.
The TC is one expense that at the moment I prefer to shelve till all other concerns with the car are sorted. 99.9% of my driving is open road so the soft starts really wont matter until I have it ready for a little bit of motorsport (way down the track after paint, brakes, auto etc,
I am prepared to listen to arguments otherwise if you feel this is a mistake.
As always Kevin, I welcome your input
Cheers
Most of this stuff I have to import from the states at huge expense.
I am also looking to bring in a built up 700r4 as I have been told my 83 700r4 is unlikely to last the extra stress the vortec 350 will place upon it. I have trouble trusting local auto shops as US trans' are not that common here and I don't want to pay 3K+ for a trans build only to have it go belly up on me.
The TC is one expense that at the moment I prefer to shelve till all other concerns with the car are sorted. 99.9% of my driving is open road so the soft starts really wont matter until I have it ready for a little bit of motorsport (way down the track after paint, brakes, auto etc,
I am prepared to listen to arguments otherwise if you feel this is a mistake.
As always Kevin, I welcome your input
Cheers
#156
Supreme Member
iTrader: (13)
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Bowdon, GA.
Posts: 2,535
Likes: 0
Received 16 Likes
on
14 Posts
Car: 1988 Camaro
Engine: 355, 10.34:1, 249/252 @.050", IK200
Transmission: TH-400, 3500 stall 9.5" converter
Axle/Gears: Ford 9", detroit locker, 3.89 gears
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
The torque converter is one place your money really matters. I have never used the S10 unit so can't say 1st hand on that, but it sounds a lot like the 1970's and 80's "use a vega converter" trend to me. The stock chevy vegas had higher stall speed, so people would use those behind their hot rod engines.. You ended up with a weak converter that had a good flah stall, thats it.
Much more to a converter than that. I have used B&M, TCI, GER, etc. Not really fully happy with any of them.
A well built custom built converter only runs $150-250 more than an off the shelf unit is is soooo much better.
I have a th-400, custom built 9.5" 3500 stall in mine. Before that was an off the shelf 11" 2800 stall.
The custom built one drives around town almost like a stock converter. The car even pulls it's self forward at idle in gear some.
The off the shelf 2800 stall, reved up much higher driving around town, car would not move at all until around 1400-1500 rpm.
Much more to a converter than that. I have used B&M, TCI, GER, etc. Not really fully happy with any of them.
A well built custom built converter only runs $150-250 more than an off the shelf unit is is soooo much better.
I have a th-400, custom built 9.5" 3500 stall in mine. Before that was an off the shelf 11" 2800 stall.
The custom built one drives around town almost like a stock converter. The car even pulls it's self forward at idle in gear some.
The off the shelf 2800 stall, reved up much higher driving around town, car would not move at all until around 1400-1500 rpm.
#157
Supreme Member
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Hurst, Texas
Posts: 9,994
Received 386 Likes
on
329 Posts
Car: 1983 G20 Chevy
Engine: 305 TPI
Transmission: 4L60
Axle/Gears: 14 bolt with 3.07 gears
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
The torque converter is one place your money really matters. I have never used the S10 unit so can't say 1st hand on that, but it sounds a lot like the 1970's and 80's "use a vega converter" trend to me. The stock chevy vegas had higher stall speed, so people would use those behind their hot rod engines.. You ended up with a weak converter that had a good flah stall, thats it.
Much more to a converter than that. I have used B&M, TCI, GER, etc. Not really fully happy with any of them.
A well built custom built converter only runs $150-250 more than an off the shelf unit is is soooo much better.
I have a th-400, custom built 9.5" 3500 stall in mine. Before that was an off the shelf 11" 2800 stall.
The custom built one drives around town almost like a stock converter. The car even pulls it's self forward at idle in gear some.
The off the shelf 2800 stall, reved up much higher driving around town, car would not move at all until around 1400-1500 rpm.
Much more to a converter than that. I have used B&M, TCI, GER, etc. Not really fully happy with any of them.
A well built custom built converter only runs $150-250 more than an off the shelf unit is is soooo much better.
I have a th-400, custom built 9.5" 3500 stall in mine. Before that was an off the shelf 11" 2800 stall.
The custom built one drives around town almost like a stock converter. The car even pulls it's self forward at idle in gear some.
The off the shelf 2800 stall, reved up much higher driving around town, car would not move at all until around 1400-1500 rpm.
#158
Supreme Member
iTrader: (13)
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Bowdon, GA.
Posts: 2,535
Likes: 0
Received 16 Likes
on
14 Posts
Car: 1988 Camaro
Engine: 355, 10.34:1, 249/252 @.050", IK200
Transmission: TH-400, 3500 stall 9.5" converter
Axle/Gears: Ford 9", detroit locker, 3.89 gears
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Far from the Vega converter fad. The S10 converter has the same stator as a LT1 Corvette converter with the "K" 2025 rpm stall speed. I saw a car move to a "custom built 3,000 rpm" stall that was supposed to match the build and witnessed the car slow down 2 tenths and lose 2 mph. Being an OEM converter it is driveable at part-throttle at less than 1,000 rpm and shift recovery was 2-300 rpm higher than the factory 1,600 rpm converter.
Yes you are correct, not all "custom" converters are good. I like PTC, Jakes performance, Yank.. Freakshow converters, FTI, Edge converters, ATI, roadrunner converters, midwest converters, coan.
#159
Supreme Member
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
From my personal experience (and you all can guess my HP and torque levels from my signature), my 700 has held up so far. It’s out of an early 90s Caprice and has the basic mods (.500" boost valve, TransGo Stage II shift kit, Corvette servo, etc) and has seen time on a builders bench reportedly to have had better clutches and steels installed. I beat the crap out that thing. I even towed a covered U-Haul trailer 3500 kms with no functional lock-up and engine temps in the 240 range (over 4 days @ 10 hours a day) and it’s still around and performing as well as it ever has. The engine failed shortly after that trip. Rod bearings went out of it. Now at half a dozen seasons and well over 50 000 miles on it. Is that an exception.? Possibly. Then again, 350-400 hp and torque isn't all THAT much.
My thinking is that the OP (Geoff aka Loopy) install the stocker and drive. There’s certainly NO sense in putting ANY kind if converter in the stock transmission unless you’re willing to say goodbye to it after the transmission shreds and fills everything full of clutch material and metal. (I suppose if an S10 converter comes your way for next to the nothing and you've yet to put the drivetrain together, then you haven't got anything to lose really. You'll certainly find out what having a little flash stall will do to wake up a performance package)
Just keep a tow truck number on speed dial so you can get home...
My thinking is that the OP (Geoff aka Loopy) install the stocker and drive. There’s certainly NO sense in putting ANY kind if converter in the stock transmission unless you’re willing to say goodbye to it after the transmission shreds and fills everything full of clutch material and metal. (I suppose if an S10 converter comes your way for next to the nothing and you've yet to put the drivetrain together, then you haven't got anything to lose really. You'll certainly find out what having a little flash stall will do to wake up a performance package)
Just keep a tow truck number on speed dial so you can get home...
Last edited by skinny z; 12-20-2014 at 11:48 AM.
#160
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Geoff aka Loopy) install the stocker and drive. There’s certainly NO sense in putting ANY kind if converter in the stock transmission unless you’re willing to say goodbye to it after the transmission shreds and fills everything full of clutch material and metal. (I suppose if an S10 converter comes your way for next to the nothing and you've yet to put the drivetrain together, then you haven't got anything to lose really. You'll certainly find out what having a little flash stall will do to wake up a performance package)
Just keep a tow truck number on speed dial so you can get home...
Just keep a tow truck number on speed dial so you can get home...
Maybe theres some steps I can take to help longevity such as servos, input drum, whatever etc
Would be interesting to hear some opinions about this......
#161
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Originally Posted by Fast355
Far from the Vega converter fad. The S10 converter has the same stator as a LT1 Corvette converter with the "K" 2025 rpm stall speed. I saw a car move to a "custom built 3,000 rpm" stall that was supposed to match the build and witnessed the car slow down 2 tenths and lose 2 mph. Being an OEM converter it is driveable at part-throttle at less than 1,000 rpm and shift recovery was 2-300 rpm higher than the factory 1,600 rpm converter.
Far from the Vega converter fad. The S10 converter has the same stator as a LT1 Corvette converter with the "K" 2025 rpm stall speed. I saw a car move to a "custom built 3,000 rpm" stall that was supposed to match the build and witnessed the car slow down 2 tenths and lose 2 mph. Being an OEM converter it is driveable at part-throttle at less than 1,000 rpm and shift recovery was 2-300 rpm higher than the factory 1,600 rpm converter.
Hmmm, that's great info to know. Like I said, I have no 1st hand dealings with the S10 converter.
Yes you are correct, not all "custom" converters are good. I like PTC, Jakes performance, Yank.. Freakshow converters, FTI, Edge converters, ATI, roadrunner converters, midwest converters, coan.
Yes you are correct, not all "custom" converters are good. I like PTC, Jakes performance, Yank.. Freakshow converters, FTI, Edge converters, ATI, roadrunner converters, midwest converters, coan.
Interesting reading here, would be keen to hear more.
Thanks!
#162
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Ok, some news about the heads etc.
The engine shop has blended the ports, done the screw in studs and guide plates and
measured the Alexs springs. The springs are exactly as advertised.
The head volume was only 62 CC so static comp ratio at this point is looking
to be 9.8:1 (this based on my measurements of deck height)
The snag is, the machining on the heads and block is too coarse to use shim gaskets.
I can get the heads and block machined to smooth them for a cost of $320, or get
just the block decked and use a thicker gasket.
Based on the machinists advice, I have decided to go with that as the cost to deck the block is only $160 vs $320 for both.
We will use a .040" felpro gasket to maintain the piston to head clearance and optimum quench value.
He wants me to get the scat rods and he will mock up the engine to check all measurements and clearances before machining.
Does that sound all good to you Kevin?
Cheers
The engine shop has blended the ports, done the screw in studs and guide plates and
measured the Alexs springs. The springs are exactly as advertised.
The head volume was only 62 CC so static comp ratio at this point is looking
to be 9.8:1 (this based on my measurements of deck height)
The snag is, the machining on the heads and block is too coarse to use shim gaskets.
I can get the heads and block machined to smooth them for a cost of $320, or get
just the block decked and use a thicker gasket.
Based on the machinists advice, I have decided to go with that as the cost to deck the block is only $160 vs $320 for both.
We will use a .040" felpro gasket to maintain the piston to head clearance and optimum quench value.
He wants me to get the scat rods and he will mock up the engine to check all measurements and clearances before machining.
Does that sound all good to you Kevin?
Cheers
#163
Supreme Member
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Certainly get the engine mocked up before you make a decision.
One thing to consider is how important achieving exactly .040" quench is to you. Is it worth the cost of machining? And I ask this because you had commented on your limiting the costs where possible.
Having said that, personally, the idea of a zero deck makes me nervous. It leaves no room for the next go around should there need to be one in the fututre. My current block has a .014" deck and I use the Victor Reinz 5647 head gasket for the "magical" .040" squish.
I'd like to run all of your numbers again regarding SCR and DCR and see where you might be at. I'm still thinking of low octane fuel.
Gotta go now but I'll be back.
One thing to consider is how important achieving exactly .040" quench is to you. Is it worth the cost of machining? And I ask this because you had commented on your limiting the costs where possible.
Having said that, personally, the idea of a zero deck makes me nervous. It leaves no room for the next go around should there need to be one in the fututre. My current block has a .014" deck and I use the Victor Reinz 5647 head gasket for the "magical" .040" squish.
I'd like to run all of your numbers again regarding SCR and DCR and see where you might be at. I'm still thinking of low octane fuel.
Gotta go now but I'll be back.
#164
Supreme Member
iTrader: (13)
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Bowdon, GA.
Posts: 2,535
Likes: 0
Received 16 Likes
on
14 Posts
Car: 1988 Camaro
Engine: 355, 10.34:1, 249/252 @.050", IK200
Transmission: TH-400, 3500 stall 9.5" converter
Axle/Gears: Ford 9", detroit locker, 3.89 gears
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Decking the block is a great idea. If the budget is there for it, I recommed that every time. It just opens up so many more head gasket options for you.
With the stock decks, you only have a few options.. Fel pro 1094, 7733sh1, mr. gasket 1130G
With any major cut or 0 decked block you have atleast 15 choices for head gaskets.
Now Like Skinny said, I would think about down the road rebuild too. If 0 decked now, what happens 5 years from now if it needs a small shave.
I would look at maybe getting the decks cut to leave .010, .012, .014" piston in hole.
Then just go with .026, .027, .028, .030, .032 gaskets in that range there is at least 8 gaskets to pick from.
With the stock decks, you only have a few options.. Fel pro 1094, 7733sh1, mr. gasket 1130G
With any major cut or 0 decked block you have atleast 15 choices for head gaskets.
Now Like Skinny said, I would think about down the road rebuild too. If 0 decked now, what happens 5 years from now if it needs a small shave.
I would look at maybe getting the decks cut to leave .010, .012, .014" piston in hole.
Then just go with .026, .027, .028, .030, .032 gaskets in that range there is at least 8 gaskets to pick from.
#165
Supreme Member
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Not to be too sinister about it but I DO have a question about the opinion of your machinist and how he knows the heads and block are unsuitable for the use of a shim gasket. They are new after all and it would seem to me they'd have a surface that's smooth enough and straight enough. I can't say for certain and having never used a shim myself, I have no experience in that regard. I'd just wouldn't want to see you handing money over to your guy when it's possible you might not have to.
This isn't to take away from the benefits of having a new deck as Nightrider points out however at this level of build there may be places the money is better spent.
Just putting that out there.
PS. What are the SCR and DCR scenarios just to refresh...
This isn't to take away from the benefits of having a new deck as Nightrider points out however at this level of build there may be places the money is better spent.
Just putting that out there.
PS. What are the SCR and DCR scenarios just to refresh...
#166
Supreme Member
iTrader: (13)
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Bowdon, GA.
Posts: 2,535
Likes: 0
Received 16 Likes
on
14 Posts
Car: 1988 Camaro
Engine: 355, 10.34:1, 249/252 @.050", IK200
Transmission: TH-400, 3500 stall 9.5" converter
Axle/Gears: Ford 9", detroit locker, 3.89 gears
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
I want to share something but I don't want anyone to take this as a fact and it will work every time. I know the risk and I took it, and it worked out for me.
A lot of people gets nervous about shim gaskets and thinks the surfaces must be almost glass smooth.
I have used 1094's sprayed with copper seal a gasket on factory stock 200K + mile decks/heads MANY times.. I used a file to draw across the surfaces to knock down any high spots, then used scotch brite roto pads on an angle air die grinder to prep/clean surfaces, then 1500 grit sandpaper pads on grinder over the surfaces, blow off, wipe down with paint thinner, blow dry.. I have done this MANY times with no ill results.
The high/low spots are the problem not so much the smoothness. The shims can't fill in any voids in the decks and can't compress to take up any high spots.
You knock down high spots with a file and spray both sides of gasket with copper coat and that fills any voids.
A lot of people gets nervous about shim gaskets and thinks the surfaces must be almost glass smooth.
I have used 1094's sprayed with copper seal a gasket on factory stock 200K + mile decks/heads MANY times.. I used a file to draw across the surfaces to knock down any high spots, then used scotch brite roto pads on an angle air die grinder to prep/clean surfaces, then 1500 grit sandpaper pads on grinder over the surfaces, blow off, wipe down with paint thinner, blow dry.. I have done this MANY times with no ill results.
The high/low spots are the problem not so much the smoothness. The shims can't fill in any voids in the decks and can't compress to take up any high spots.
You knock down high spots with a file and spray both sides of gasket with copper coat and that fills any voids.
#167
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Not to be too sinister about it but I DO have a question about the opinion of your machinist and how he knows the heads and block are unsuitable for the use of a shim gasket. They are new after all and it would seem to me they'd have a surface that's smooth enough and straight enough.
Having said that, personally, the idea of a zero deck makes me nervous. It leaves no room for the next go around should there need to be one in the fututre. My current block has a .014" deck and I use the Victor Reinz 5647 head gasket for the "magical" .040" squish.
PS. What are the SCR and DCR scenarios just to refresh...
Having said that, personally, the idea of a zero deck makes me nervous. It leaves no room for the next go around should there need to be one in the fututre. My current block has a .014" deck and I use the Victor Reinz 5647 head gasket for the "magical" .040" squish.
PS. What are the SCR and DCR scenarios just to refresh...
I do 100% agree abut the 0 decking being a bit short-sighted.
I will go and pay for the heads which are now finished and get a photo of the markings for you guys to look at.
I haven't re-run the DCR figures so Don't have an answer for that yet
Last edited by loopy; 12-30-2014 at 06:35 PM.
#168
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Decking the block is a great idea. If the budget is there for it, I recommed that every time. It just opens up so many more head gasket options for you.
With the stock decks, you only have a few options.. Fel pro 1094, 7733sh1, mr. gasket 1130G
With any major cut or 0 decked block you have atleast 15 choices for head gaskets.
Now Like Skinny said, I would think about down the road rebuild too. If 0 decked now, what happens 5 years from now if it needs a small shave.
I would look at maybe getting the decks cut to leave .010, .012, .014" piston in hole.
Then just go with .026, .027, .028, .030, .032 gaskets in that range there is at least 8 gaskets to pick from.
With the stock decks, you only have a few options.. Fel pro 1094, 7733sh1, mr. gasket 1130G
With any major cut or 0 decked block you have atleast 15 choices for head gaskets.
Now Like Skinny said, I would think about down the road rebuild too. If 0 decked now, what happens 5 years from now if it needs a small shave.
I would look at maybe getting the decks cut to leave .010, .012, .014" piston in hole.
Then just go with .026, .027, .028, .030, .032 gaskets in that range there is at least 8 gaskets to pick from.
I totally agree with this Nightrider, that was my thoughts while he was talking with me about it, thats why I came back to you guys for advice.
My machinist seems to think the .040" Felpro is the king of gaskets and really pushed for these. I my self don't have an opinion about gaskets either way, no experience at all, apart from having used felpro way back when I was young on a 351C build for my fairlane.
At the end of the day it will be my decision, my expense so he will have to go with what we decide here.
Last edited by loopy; 12-30-2014 at 06:30 PM.
#170
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Skinny,
The machinist measure the heads at just on 62CC.
He then calculated SCR as 9.8:1.
He did this on a pad, didn't use any computer based calculator.
I haven't had time to sit down and rerun the numbers yet.
His calculation was based on deck height of .025"
The machinist measure the heads at just on 62CC.
He then calculated SCR as 9.8:1.
He did this on a pad, didn't use any computer based calculator.
I haven't had time to sit down and rerun the numbers yet.
His calculation was based on deck height of .025"
#171
Supreme Member
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
I totally agree with this Nightrider, that was my thoughts while he was talking with me about it, thats why I came back to you guys for advice.
My machinist seems to think the .040" Felpro is the king of gaskets and really pushed for these. I my self don't have an opinion about gaskets either way, no experience at all, apart from having used felpro way back when I was young on a 351C build for my fairlane.
At the end of the day it will be my decision, my expense so he will have to go with what we decide here.
My machinist seems to think the .040" Felpro is the king of gaskets and really pushed for these. I my self don't have an opinion about gaskets either way, no experience at all, apart from having used felpro way back when I was young on a 351C build for my fairlane.
At the end of the day it will be my decision, my expense so he will have to go with what we decide here.
Of course if you want to pull the trigger now, that's your call. Ultimately you'll have a well thought out engine. It's just a matter of flexibilty down the road.
Your machinist has based his estimates on an assumed deck height. Have the block assembled with your new rods and get a measurement as has been suggested. You can make an informed choice at that point.
Last edited by skinny z; 12-30-2014 at 07:29 PM.
#172
Supreme Member
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
The time now is 6:30 pm MST (Alberta, Canada). I'm guessing 11:30 am, New Years Eve, in Blenheim, NZ. (I suppose I could look it up)
#173
Supreme Member
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Hurst, Texas
Posts: 9,994
Received 386 Likes
on
329 Posts
Car: 1983 G20 Chevy
Engine: 305 TPI
Transmission: 4L60
Axle/Gears: 14 bolt with 3.07 gears
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Certainly get the engine mocked up before you make a decision.
One thing to consider is how important achieving exactly .040" quench is to you. Is it worth the cost of machining? And I ask this because you had commented on your limiting the costs where possible.
Having said that, personally, the idea of a zero deck makes me nervous. It leaves no room for the next go around should there need to be one in the fututre. My current block has a .014" deck and I use the Victor Reinz 5647 head gasket for the "magical" .040" squish.
I'd like to run all of your numbers again regarding SCR and DCR and see where you might be at. I'm still thinking of low octane fuel.
Gotta go now but I'll be back.
One thing to consider is how important achieving exactly .040" quench is to you. Is it worth the cost of machining? And I ask this because you had commented on your limiting the costs where possible.
Having said that, personally, the idea of a zero deck makes me nervous. It leaves no room for the next go around should there need to be one in the fututre. My current block has a .014" deck and I use the Victor Reinz 5647 head gasket for the "magical" .040" squish.
I'd like to run all of your numbers again regarding SCR and DCR and see where you might be at. I'm still thinking of low octane fuel.
Gotta go now but I'll be back.
#174
Supreme Member
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
You can run the piston out of the top of the deck with a thicker head gasket should the need arrive. The last engine I had built 1.56" compression height on a milled deck and the pistons sat 0.05" out of/above the deck. I used a 0.43" compressed head gasket for a 0.038" quench.
#175
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
I received this at 2.30 pm NZ Kevin
I can wait to rerun numbers mate. It'll be 2 or more weeks before any rods even turn up for mocking up the block.
Just an aside, they sent me a bill for head work $876 nzd. This after estimating the work at $500 plus GST. I wasn't too impressed and rang them. Thankfully they have decided to honor the original amount discussed . I just hope they don't think they can make the shortfall out of me during the next stage of my engine work.
Last edited by loopy; 12-30-2014 at 08:48 PM.
#176
Supreme Member
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
I received this at 2.30 pm NZ Kevin
I can wait to rerun numbers mate. It'll be 2 or more weeks before any rods even turn up for mocking up the block.
Just an aside, they sent me a bill for head work $876 nzd. This after estimating the work at $500 plus GST. I wasn't too impressed and rang them. Thankfully they have decided to honor the original amount discussed . I just hope they don't think they can make the shortfall out of me during the next stage of my engine work.
I can wait to rerun numbers mate. It'll be 2 or more weeks before any rods even turn up for mocking up the block.
Just an aside, they sent me a bill for head work $876 nzd. This after estimating the work at $500 plus GST. I wasn't too impressed and rang them. Thankfully they have decided to honor the original amount discussed . I just hope they don't think they can make the shortfall out of me during the next stage of my engine work.
Seems to me you're more than halfway there. Additional machining notwithstanding.
Do you intend to assemble the shortblock yourself? For what it's worth, I'd have a shop do it. If for nothing else other than having those nice new rods of yours and their ARP bolts stretched the appropriate amount. Plus all of the clearances can be checked and resolved without any additional effort on your part. Except opening your wallet.
Edit: The rods made sense in that they're almost the cost of having your others resized plus the bolts. (I hope you got the old ones back as cores you could sell). The machine work on the heads was a necessary evil however having him dig into the porting (bowl work and gasket matching ) I feel is a waste of time. For what it's worth, gasket matching returns very small yields on the investment. The bowl work, that's generally worth it.
Be careful....
Last edited by skinny z; 12-30-2014 at 11:38 PM.
#177
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Good advice.
I haven't had any gasket matching done. All he has done is light port work removing the casting marks and smoothing the bowl radius's.
He reckons he has 10hrs work in it, that's with the screw-in studs and all the rest.
I was going to get him to do all assembly and have him onsite for the initial start up and running.
TBH, I just don't have the confidence to do it myself.
Anyways, off to a local pub for new years.
Have a good New years mate, thanks for all your help, and don't get in too much trouble tonight eh!
Same goes for all you other guys who have chimed in and helped in this thread, thanks very much and have good one !
Cheers
Geoff
I haven't had any gasket matching done. All he has done is light port work removing the casting marks and smoothing the bowl radius's.
He reckons he has 10hrs work in it, that's with the screw-in studs and all the rest.
I was going to get him to do all assembly and have him onsite for the initial start up and running.
TBH, I just don't have the confidence to do it myself.
Anyways, off to a local pub for new years.
Have a good New years mate, thanks for all your help, and don't get in too much trouble tonight eh!
Same goes for all you other guys who have chimed in and helped in this thread, thanks very much and have good one !
Cheers
Geoff
#178
Supreme Member
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
This is with a cam very similar to the XR276HR. My custom spec'd grind. Less advertised duration but more lift. The video doesn't really do the sound justice but you get the idea. That's at about 850 RPM. At 650, it has a more pronouced lope but nothing compared to a big cammed sound. After all it's a little cam by most standards.
Last edited by skinny z; 01-01-2015 at 02:53 PM.
#180
Supreme Member
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
That's an interesting question Geoff and one that HAD a simple answer.
The plan was to get a new cam to compliment my new heads. RHS Pro Torker. They're essentially an upgraded version of the OEM Vortecs. Bigger valves. More port flow with the same sized runners. While the Vortecs are flow limited at lifts (arguably) beyond .500", the RHS heads extend that past .550". I needed a cam to suit. I didn't want to increase the duration as the old short block had a low piston to deck value and my max SCR was about 10:1. Any more cam would have killed some the low speed torque that set my car apart from a lot of others. I was also running the OEM rods and cast crank although I did have ARP rod bolts. My target RPMs were below 6000. The Comp lobe catalog had a couple of grinds that kept the .050" duration values the same but lift went up about 7%. Those heads and cam installed in the old short yeilded a DCR of about 8:1. That was up from the previous DCR of 7.93 (with the 276 cam). Pretty much the same.
Well that didn't last long. I had problems with that short block and had to take it out of service (another story in itself).
Enter the new short block. With a better piston to deck relationship of .014" and my .026" gasket I had a quench of .040" (nice) and an SCR of 10.4:1 and a DCR of 8.4:1. My cranking pressures were 205 psi+. That proved problematic. I think I touched on the troubles I had with detonation and ignition timing. Ultimately I had the heads worked over to add a couple of cc's to the chambers and fattened up the head gasket. Now the DCR is 7.94:1. Cranking pressures about 185-190 psi.
From the simulated data, I've gained about 20 ft/lbs of torque at the same 4000 rpm. HP goes up accordingly. These heads have a lot more in them. If I were to do it over again, I'd keep the 10.4:1 SCR but just go bigger on the cam to keep the DCR streetable. This short has a forged crank and Elgin rods so the usuable RPM range has been extended. I could easily (and have) spin to 7000 rpm. No point with my little cam though. Maybe the next build when I'll give up my fuel economy for the sake of an 11 second time slip.
XR276HR Old Shortblock
274 Cam Old Shortblock
274 Cam New Shortblock High Compression
274 Can New Shortblock Low Compression
The plan was to get a new cam to compliment my new heads. RHS Pro Torker. They're essentially an upgraded version of the OEM Vortecs. Bigger valves. More port flow with the same sized runners. While the Vortecs are flow limited at lifts (arguably) beyond .500", the RHS heads extend that past .550". I needed a cam to suit. I didn't want to increase the duration as the old short block had a low piston to deck value and my max SCR was about 10:1. Any more cam would have killed some the low speed torque that set my car apart from a lot of others. I was also running the OEM rods and cast crank although I did have ARP rod bolts. My target RPMs were below 6000. The Comp lobe catalog had a couple of grinds that kept the .050" duration values the same but lift went up about 7%. Those heads and cam installed in the old short yeilded a DCR of about 8:1. That was up from the previous DCR of 7.93 (with the 276 cam). Pretty much the same.
Well that didn't last long. I had problems with that short block and had to take it out of service (another story in itself).
Enter the new short block. With a better piston to deck relationship of .014" and my .026" gasket I had a quench of .040" (nice) and an SCR of 10.4:1 and a DCR of 8.4:1. My cranking pressures were 205 psi+. That proved problematic. I think I touched on the troubles I had with detonation and ignition timing. Ultimately I had the heads worked over to add a couple of cc's to the chambers and fattened up the head gasket. Now the DCR is 7.94:1. Cranking pressures about 185-190 psi.
From the simulated data, I've gained about 20 ft/lbs of torque at the same 4000 rpm. HP goes up accordingly. These heads have a lot more in them. If I were to do it over again, I'd keep the 10.4:1 SCR but just go bigger on the cam to keep the DCR streetable. This short has a forged crank and Elgin rods so the usuable RPM range has been extended. I could easily (and have) spin to 7000 rpm. No point with my little cam though. Maybe the next build when I'll give up my fuel economy for the sake of an 11 second time slip.
XR276HR Old Shortblock
274 Cam Old Shortblock
274 Cam New Shortblock High Compression
274 Can New Shortblock Low Compression
Last edited by skinny z; 01-04-2015 at 12:51 PM.
#182
Supreme Member
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Based on my trap speed, ET and weight (12.6, 107.5 and 3650 respectively) it looks to be in the 400's, yes. Some calculators suggest 360 rwhp/430 chp. Encouraging but optimistic I'd think.
Steady state highway mpg are about 22 imperial. Not the best I've seen and they seem to have worsened slightly not from the heads and cam but from the (poorly chosen) switch from my 670 Holley Street Avenger to a 750 Barry Grant Speed Demon. I picked up the BG because it had been modfied for full air bleed adjustability (which was a tuning aid I was after) however the low speed drivability has withered somewhat. Depending on how this new racing season pans out in early testing, I may move to a 600 cfm carb. I've found a couple that offer the tunability I'm looking for in the smaller size. 600 cfm is enough for my application.
At any rate, I hope you can benefit from my experimentation. I've only offered advice based on my experiences. Both good and not so good.
Steady state highway mpg are about 22 imperial. Not the best I've seen and they seem to have worsened slightly not from the heads and cam but from the (poorly chosen) switch from my 670 Holley Street Avenger to a 750 Barry Grant Speed Demon. I picked up the BG because it had been modfied for full air bleed adjustability (which was a tuning aid I was after) however the low speed drivability has withered somewhat. Depending on how this new racing season pans out in early testing, I may move to a 600 cfm carb. I've found a couple that offer the tunability I'm looking for in the smaller size. 600 cfm is enough for my application.
At any rate, I hope you can benefit from my experimentation. I've only offered advice based on my experiences. Both good and not so good.
#183
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Keep it coming mate. I have learnt a lot from your experience. Your posts are comprehensive and easy to understand (for a newb like me)
I shudder to think what I would have ended up with if I followed the advice from the shop where I brought my engine!
I shudder to think what I would have ended up with if I followed the advice from the shop where I brought my engine!
#184
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
I may move to a 600 cfm carb. I've found a couple that offer the tunability I'm looking for in the smaller size. 600 cfm is enough for my application.
At any rate, I hope you can benefit from my experimentation. I've only offered advice based on my experiences. Both good and not so good.
At any rate, I hope you can benefit from my experimentation. I've only offered advice based on my experiences. Both good and not so good.
#185
Supreme Member
iTrader: (13)
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Bowdon, GA.
Posts: 2,535
Likes: 0
Received 16 Likes
on
14 Posts
Car: 1988 Camaro
Engine: 355, 10.34:1, 249/252 @.050", IK200
Transmission: TH-400, 3500 stall 9.5" converter
Axle/Gears: Ford 9", detroit locker, 3.89 gears
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Not sure if you want vac or mech. sec but holley street HP line has a 650 cfm with adjustable air bleeds but it's mech. sec.. Also the classic HP line has a 600 cfm, adj. air bleeds, but again mech. sec.
#186
Junior Member
Join Date: Sep 2014
Location: Wellsford ,NZ
Posts: 59
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Car: 83 firebird 500 le
Engine: 350 chevy with 305 heads
Transmission: street/strip 700r4
Axle/Gears: chevy 10 bolt
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
The snag is, the machining on the heads and block is too coarse to use shim gasket.
[Quote]
What a shame you don't live up closer to me mate cause I work in an engineering shop we recondition engines and remetal an remanufacture whitemetal bearings So we have all the gear to do that!
[Quote]
What a shame you don't live up closer to me mate cause I work in an engineering shop we recondition engines and remetal an remanufacture whitemetal bearings So we have all the gear to do that!
#187
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
[QUOTE=natdowson;5861902]The snag is, the machining on the heads and block is too coarse to use shim gasket.
What a shame you don't live up closer to me mate cause I work in an engineering shop we recondition engines and remetal an remanufacture whitemetal bearings So we have all the gear to do that! lol story of my life Nat
What a shame you don't live up closer to me mate cause I work in an engineering shop we recondition engines and remetal an remanufacture whitemetal bearings So we have all the gear to do that!
#188
Supreme Member
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
I've seen those but as you mention they're mechanical secondary and for my application, not what I'm after. That's not to say they wouldn't do the job and perform well at the dragstrip but a VS carb would provide every bit the same performance while at the same time, deliver better fuel economy.
#189
Supreme Member
iTrader: (13)
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Bowdon, GA.
Posts: 2,535
Likes: 0
Received 16 Likes
on
14 Posts
Car: 1988 Camaro
Engine: 355, 10.34:1, 249/252 @.050", IK200
Transmission: TH-400, 3500 stall 9.5" converter
Axle/Gears: Ford 9", detroit locker, 3.89 gears
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Yeah, Skinny I kinda figured you were after a vac sec. I agree with you fully, I only like the mech. sec carbs on more track use than street cars.
I have the holley 4150 HP 750 mech. sec on my camaro.. Great carb, love it on the track. Hate the fuel mileage, but this car is more track that street now.
I have the holley 4150 HP 750 mech. sec on my camaro.. Great carb, love it on the track. Hate the fuel mileage, but this car is more track that street now.
#190
Supreme Member
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
"Track car" being the operative phrase here.
The rule of thumb, (as I understand it) is that if power below peak torque is not of a concern as would be the case in a dedicated drag car with a high stall converter or a stick, then a mech carb is entirely suitable. There's no downside to using a vac carb in that case but it does add another element of tuning to the mix.
That said, I'm vac sec all the way. I spend a lot of my driving in and around the city. Having a converter that always has my rpm at 2000 or more doesn't help much but the vac carb acts like it's very small and with only the single accelerator pump to deal with, in the city mileage isn't entirely off the wall.
The rule of thumb, (as I understand it) is that if power below peak torque is not of a concern as would be the case in a dedicated drag car with a high stall converter or a stick, then a mech carb is entirely suitable. There's no downside to using a vac carb in that case but it does add another element of tuning to the mix.
That said, I'm vac sec all the way. I spend a lot of my driving in and around the city. Having a converter that always has my rpm at 2000 or more doesn't help much but the vac carb acts like it's very small and with only the single accelerator pump to deal with, in the city mileage isn't entirely off the wall.
#191
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Can anyone comfirm that this is the correct part number for the scat rods for an L31 block
3-ICR5700P
Theres also this one at summit http://www.summitracing.com/int/part...-size/5-7l-350
I assume they are the next up the chain so to speak
Cheers
3-ICR5700P
Theres also this one at summit http://www.summitracing.com/int/part...-size/5-7l-350
I assume they are the next up the chain so to speak
Cheers
Last edited by loopy; 01-10-2015 at 03:44 PM.
#192
Supreme Member
#194
Supreme Member
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Theres also this one at summit http://www.summitracing.com/int/part...-size/5-7l-350
I assume they are the next up the chain so to speak
Cheers
Also yes.
#196
Supreme Member
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
#197
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Awesome, thanks.
I thought they were but preferred to have it confirmed by someone that actually knows what he is talking about rather than assuming I was correct.
My Camaro chewed up a fan belt last weekend on the way back from Nelson after visiting Simon (Z28NZ from this forum). I have no warning lights and didn't notice the temp gauge until I heard a faint whistle from the engine bay. Turns out it was the sound of the steam coming out of the radiator overflow bottle.
I was in the middle of no-where with no cellphone coverage.
Luckily for me a passer by noticed me waving my cellphone around try to find some coverage and stopped. He was on his way home from a holdiday and still had quite a ways to go but still came back to offer help.
He ran me to the nearest town to get a belt and then back to the same place a 2nd time due to the belt being in the wrong packaging.
He helped fit the belt(he is a mechanic) and got me going again.
Turns out he owns 2 third gens both T/A's. Quite surprising really as they are not that common over here.
Anyways, luckily after a couple of runs it seems I have had no problems due to the overheat and am counting my blessings both for that and the unexpected help.
I thought they were but preferred to have it confirmed by someone that actually knows what he is talking about rather than assuming I was correct.
My Camaro chewed up a fan belt last weekend on the way back from Nelson after visiting Simon (Z28NZ from this forum). I have no warning lights and didn't notice the temp gauge until I heard a faint whistle from the engine bay. Turns out it was the sound of the steam coming out of the radiator overflow bottle.
I was in the middle of no-where with no cellphone coverage.
Luckily for me a passer by noticed me waving my cellphone around try to find some coverage and stopped. He was on his way home from a holdiday and still had quite a ways to go but still came back to offer help.
He ran me to the nearest town to get a belt and then back to the same place a 2nd time due to the belt being in the wrong packaging.
He helped fit the belt(he is a mechanic) and got me going again.
Turns out he owns 2 third gens both T/A's. Quite surprising really as they are not that common over here.
Anyways, luckily after a couple of runs it seems I have had no problems due to the overheat and am counting my blessings both for that and the unexpected help.
#198
Supreme Member
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Car people can be like that sometimes.
Nice story.
Nice story.
#199
Supreme Member
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
#200
Re: Can you check my vortec swap list and cam advice please
Thanks Kevin, I really like the look of that. I have contacted him.
Just a quick question. I tried to get the VR head gaskets you suggested from Summit and they don't seem to have them.
Where do you buy yours?
Just a quick question. I tried to get the VR head gaskets you suggested from Summit and they don't seem to have them.
Where do you buy yours?
Last edited by loopy; 01-17-2015 at 02:14 PM.