Anybody have bad luck with Ignition modules?
#1
Supreme Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Mesquite, Texas
Posts: 4,009
Likes: 0
Received 5 Likes
on
5 Posts
Car: 89 rs, 86 Trans Am
Engine: RS-V6... Trans Am-LG4
Transmission: RS-T5... Trans Am 700r4
Anybody have bad luck with Ignition modules?
Going to replace my Ignition module. I would usually go with Delco, but it seems Delco is nothing but Chinese crap now.
Of these brands, which one would you say is the best?
Wells
Borg Warner
Delphi (I know basically Delco)
SMP (Standard Motor Products)
Echlin (NAPA)
Of course there is the possibility that they are all made in the same chinese plant, and the name slapped on them is dependent on which day of the week they are made...
Of these brands, which one would you say is the best?
Wells
Borg Warner
Delphi (I know basically Delco)
SMP (Standard Motor Products)
Echlin (NAPA)
Of course there is the possibility that they are all made in the same chinese plant, and the name slapped on them is dependent on which day of the week they are made...
Last edited by 58mark; 12-06-2013 at 03:19 PM.
#2
Supreme Member
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Northwest Ohio
Posts: 6,273
Likes: 0
Received 23 Likes
on
18 Posts
Car: 1991 Camaro RS
Engine: BBC 509 Merlin ii 9.6:1 pump gas
Transmission: ATI pro th350 sfi case. TSI 5500 st
Axle/Gears: Strange S60 4:10s
Re: Anybody have bad luck with Ignition modules?
I've had decent luck with Delco ones. Cant say anything against the other brands though as I've never tried them.
#4
Supreme Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Mesquite, Texas
Posts: 4,009
Likes: 0
Received 5 Likes
on
5 Posts
Car: 89 rs, 86 Trans Am
Engine: RS-V6... Trans Am-LG4
Transmission: RS-T5... Trans Am 700r4
Re: Anybody have bad luck with Ignition modules?
very interesting... thanks
My old one isn't even bad. but I was going to pull the Dizzy to change the o ring, so I thought it would be a good idea to put a fresh one in..the car has over 200K on it
My old one isn't even bad. but I was going to pull the Dizzy to change the o ring, so I thought it would be a good idea to put a fresh one in..the car has over 200K on it
#6
Moderator
iTrader: (2)
Re: Anybody have bad luck with Ignition modules?
I have never used heatsink compound with ICMs and never had one go bad.
I've gone so far as to mount an ICM to my inner fender with a drywall screw, no heats inking, hanging off the inner fender well, kinda to see what I could get away with. It worked flawlessly.
Heat is not usually the issue, unless it's physically on fire. The killer of ICMs is unregulated or poor voltage supply.
I've gone so far as to mount an ICM to my inner fender with a drywall screw, no heats inking, hanging off the inner fender well, kinda to see what I could get away with. It worked flawlessly.
Heat is not usually the issue, unless it's physically on fire. The killer of ICMs is unregulated or poor voltage supply.
Trending Topics
#9
Supreme Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Mesquite, Texas
Posts: 4,009
Likes: 0
Received 5 Likes
on
5 Posts
Car: 89 rs, 86 Trans Am
Engine: RS-V6... Trans Am-LG4
Transmission: RS-T5... Trans Am 700r4
Re: Anybody have bad luck with Ignition modules?
Still would like some input on which brand to buy... if it makes a difference
#11
Supreme Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Mesquite, Texas
Posts: 4,009
Likes: 0
Received 5 Likes
on
5 Posts
Car: 89 rs, 86 Trans Am
Engine: RS-V6... Trans Am-LG4
Transmission: RS-T5... Trans Am 700r4
Re: Anybody have bad luck with Ignition modules?
that's the strange thing... there's a Delphi version, and a Delco version. Same thing? Delphi is cheaper.
I have no idea.
I have no idea.
#12
Moderator
iTrader: (2)
Re: Anybody have bad luck with Ignition modules?
Init4fun; I'm very versed in electronics, I've been playing with them for years and am currently in school for electronics engineering, I understand what the ICM is "essentially".
However, in my experience and research it has become clear to me that it is not heat that kills these ICM, but an unstable or noisy voltage source.
Many people have tried moving the ICM to a remote location and using heatsinks with varying success, many still have issues with frequent ICM failure. So if the problem was heat, the large heat sink being away from a source of heat should solve tht issue, no? It rarely does. In the cases where the problem seems solved I would suspect that it was actually improved grounding or bypassed a source of poor positive voltage supply in the process.
Most of the time the solution is proper grounding between block, battery, ECM, dizzy and alternator, along with good connections (lack of corrosion) in the positive signal path which has to travel through a fair amount of wire between the alternator/battery (source) and the ICM. A little bit of corrosion on a connection or carbon build up in the ignition switch can cause positive voltage supply issues that ARE A real source of problems where the ICM, and electronics in general are concerned.
The ICM is able to work in high temperature conditions, but voltage supply is a greater issue.
Another part of this to consider is that if the voltage supply is low or unstable, the current needed to drive the coil will be higher, that will cause more heat in the output transistor. Adding a heat sink to this situation is a band aid at best, and will still fail, you're just delaying it. It is best to ensure that everything else, voltage supply wise is proper, clean and working as it should, your electronics will thank you for it.
Consider the conditions that the ICM was designed to work in. It was designed to work in the hottest spot in the engine bay, without being physically inside the engine block. Since many ICMs last for many thousands of miles in these conditions without heat sink grease from the factory, it would seem to me that the heat is not an issue, but something else is.
However, in my experience and research it has become clear to me that it is not heat that kills these ICM, but an unstable or noisy voltage source.
Many people have tried moving the ICM to a remote location and using heatsinks with varying success, many still have issues with frequent ICM failure. So if the problem was heat, the large heat sink being away from a source of heat should solve tht issue, no? It rarely does. In the cases where the problem seems solved I would suspect that it was actually improved grounding or bypassed a source of poor positive voltage supply in the process.
Most of the time the solution is proper grounding between block, battery, ECM, dizzy and alternator, along with good connections (lack of corrosion) in the positive signal path which has to travel through a fair amount of wire between the alternator/battery (source) and the ICM. A little bit of corrosion on a connection or carbon build up in the ignition switch can cause positive voltage supply issues that ARE A real source of problems where the ICM, and electronics in general are concerned.
The ICM is able to work in high temperature conditions, but voltage supply is a greater issue.
Another part of this to consider is that if the voltage supply is low or unstable, the current needed to drive the coil will be higher, that will cause more heat in the output transistor. Adding a heat sink to this situation is a band aid at best, and will still fail, you're just delaying it. It is best to ensure that everything else, voltage supply wise is proper, clean and working as it should, your electronics will thank you for it.
Consider the conditions that the ICM was designed to work in. It was designed to work in the hottest spot in the engine bay, without being physically inside the engine block. Since many ICMs last for many thousands of miles in these conditions without heat sink grease from the factory, it would seem to me that the heat is not an issue, but something else is.
Last edited by Six_Shooter; 12-07-2013 at 03:35 PM.
#13
Moderator
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Chasing Electrons
Posts: 18,399
Likes: 0
Received 215 Likes
on
201 Posts
Car: check
Engine: check
Transmission: check
Re: Anybody have bad luck with Ignition modules?
Skip the Delphi stuff, they are no longer owned by GM. Use AC Delco ICMs. Or, hit a u-pull-it yard and search for vehicles that either have low miles or a not-so-old distributor in it. Look for GM ICMs.
If looking at V8 engines, skip any module with 048 on it. The ones marked 369 are good modules to use.
RBob.
If looking at V8 engines, skip any module with 048 on it. The ones marked 369 are good modules to use.
RBob.
#14
Supreme Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Mesquite, Texas
Posts: 4,009
Likes: 0
Received 5 Likes
on
5 Posts
Car: 89 rs, 86 Trans Am
Engine: RS-V6... Trans Am-LG4
Transmission: RS-T5... Trans Am 700r4
Re: Anybody have bad luck with Ignition modules?
ordered the Delco. It was the most expensive one, hopefully it will be worth it
#15
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2005
Posts: 565
Likes: 0
Received 16 Likes
on
15 Posts
Car: 92 RS
Engine: 3.1 V6
Transmission: T5
Re: Anybody have bad luck with Ignition modules?
I have had two failures in 350,000 miles. I don't remember the last brand I put in but was either Delco or Delphi.. DO PUT the heatsink compound under it. All of my failures were heat related. I am an electrical engineer and have dealt with heat related electronic components more than once and heat will kill them over time... The heatsink compound conducts the heat away and into the dizzy plate.. Think of the compound like your thermostat.. What happens to the engine if you don't remove all that heat... My three failures would go away once it cooled down and come back after it heated up.. But, when they finally fail, they are dead...
Humorous story... I was climbing over a mountain pass and as the car heated up, it started cutting out.. Would stop and let it cool, then could go on.. Over the top of the pass it quit and wouldn't seem to cool.. Carrying tools, I pulled the icm out of the dizzy and put it in a stream from snow runoff.. That cooled it down so I could go on.. Got another 5 miles and it quit for good... No phone including no cell phone.. Coasted about 10 more miles off the mountain pass to get to a phone.. Manual trans fortunately...
Humorous story... I was climbing over a mountain pass and as the car heated up, it started cutting out.. Would stop and let it cool, then could go on.. Over the top of the pass it quit and wouldn't seem to cool.. Carrying tools, I pulled the icm out of the dizzy and put it in a stream from snow runoff.. That cooled it down so I could go on.. Got another 5 miles and it quit for good... No phone including no cell phone.. Coasted about 10 more miles off the mountain pass to get to a phone.. Manual trans fortunately...
#16
Member
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: Central Falls, Ri
Posts: 214
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Car: 92 Camaro rs ( mostly stock for now
Engine: 3.1 v6
Transmission: 700r4 with a b&m megashifter.
Axle/Gears: whatever came stock. wanna posi tho
Re: Anybody have bad luck with Ignition modules?
Have had an issue with bwd ( borg warner) advance said it had a lifetime warranty. But said only one replacement is allowed. I told them that's NOT lifetime. Threatened to sue them, got another one.
The probe I now have...the new dizzy cap screw ( of course the one near the firewall) broke just finger tightening. Now I only have one screw holding cap on. Don't have tools to remove the broken screw.
The probe I now have...the new dizzy cap screw ( of course the one near the firewall) broke just finger tightening. Now I only have one screw holding cap on. Don't have tools to remove the broken screw.
#17
Supreme Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Mesquite, Texas
Posts: 4,009
Likes: 0
Received 5 Likes
on
5 Posts
Car: 89 rs, 86 Trans Am
Engine: RS-V6... Trans Am-LG4
Transmission: RS-T5... Trans Am 700r4
Re: Anybody have bad luck with Ignition modules?
Got the new ignition module in. The old one was a cheap piece of junk that said "made in hong kong" on it. Glad I got a delco in there (even though it probably wasn't made in the US either)
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post