Sounds silly since it's just the headlight motor, but wanted to know what's best for the price? I've seen a few different ones and a few different sites all with different prices. Is a simple auto part store fine for something like this or would you advise against this?

 

Personally I would order the rebuild kit from topdownsolutions.com and fix your existing one, it fixes the weak points. This is assuming yours spins but doesn't move the head light. Otherwise I think all of the replacements are made by the same company so find your favorite sponsor on the right and order it from them