Jeffrey Fontaine

Well, though I haven't bought anything from them, I'd still suggest staying away based on my experience.

Their reverse rotation stage II water pump was out of stock from Summit (Jeg's doesn't carry) and per the site was "expected" in about 3 weeks. When the 3 weeks was up, they moved the "expected" date out another 5 weeks! Obviously indicative their parts are made overseas.

Not giving up hope, I sent an email to their C/S hoping they had some in stock and would honor Summit's price - so far it has been a week and no reply.

Shouldn't be surprised I guess, their homepage references a trade show from 2006!!!

I guess Edelbrock it is...

HTH, Jeff

Apeiron

Don't even mention Stewart and Edelbrock pumps in the same breath.

Manic Z

iTrader: (1)

Shame you feel that way. I had a great experience with their stage 2 aluminum pump for ten years and now run a stage 1 cast iron, which works great as well.

IROCThe5.7L

My Stewart is close to 10 years old. Works great still.

hellz_wings

iTrader: (2)

So the general consensus is that Stewart pumps are not a quality piece?

Apeiron

Stewart = good
Edelbrock = meh

hellz_wings

iTrader: (2)

Nice thanks!

8t2 z-chev

i always thought both were good-put an edelbrock pump
on my car in '98 and it's still going strong bearing and
seal same as used on original GM pumps.With a larger
housing and closed back impeller it pumps a little more
than stock,but no difference in cooling was noticed.

vwdave

I have one, love it.

Theit tech support is great too. The guy offered a suggestion and it actually fixed my car.

Jeffrey Fontaine

May be so, but their customer service is absent. Still haven't received a response to my email. Summit shows 5/24 shipping date... I've heard generally good things about them, but how you can be out of stock on a fairly common part for 2 months, and not answer customer emails, is beyond me.

I ended up just going with a new AC Delco piece rather than the E-brock.

87350IROC

iTrader: (2)

And did you pick up the phone? Everyone is so attached to email these days. You probably would have gotten your answer in under 5 minutes with a call.

hellz_wings

iTrader: (2)

Just remembered that mine was a Weiand aluminum water pump. It's lasted so far for 4+ years with no problems or noises and it's aluminum. Still looks good too after all these years. How long does an aluminum WP typically last?

Jeffrey Fontaine

No - because I work on a shop floor with way too much background noise during the 8a-5p they have hours. Regardless, if you run a business, and have an email posted for your customer service team, it should be responded to, simple as that. And to be out of stock for two months plus on a part that can't have that much volume is pretty poor.

To each his own, just wanted to share my experience/opinion!

actarnoff

iTrader: (1)

For what its worth, my Stage II pump developed a leak from its weeping hole after 2 years.

vwdave

Maybe your email went to their spam folder?

SumDumbGuy

I know this is way late but I'll post it anyway....
I actually work for Engineered Machined Products (the EMP in EMP-Stewart Components.) They have a leased off-site mail server and web site and they can't get ahold of their tech support on it. Last time I heard anything, they couldn't get any of their data/info from the company they're leasing from, so they're kind of forced to stay with them or redo everything from stratch.
Call them (906) 789-2816 and ask for Meagan Casey for orders, Mark Coyne for shipping.
I have a stage I, can't complain...But I've only put 1000 miles on since I installed it.

Twin_Turbo

iTrader: (25)

I run stewart pumps on all my engines, I have never had a problem with them. Super quality.

Edwardgp

There is our inside man.

articwhiteZ

iTrader: (56)

On a side Note: Edelbrock will reman there water pumps for $75.
with all new parts (would hope so)

Just so ya know

jichniow

I had a Stewart water pump on my car for several years. While it operated fine, it kept chewing up belts. Turns out the offset on the pump shaft was WAY off. Pretty bad quality escape IMO.

On the other hand, I bought an Edelbrock water pump to replace that one and it's perfect. In fact, every Edelbrock part I've ever bought has been a quality part. Not many other manufacturer's I can say that about.

Twin_Turbo

iTrader: (25)

You should always check belt alignment with aftermarket parts, could also be you used extra thick gaskets.

Justins86bird

When my pump went, I got a stage I. Always ran hot at idle after that. I finally switched to a autozone water pump and it ran cooler. In my case, the $30 with lifetime warranty was better then the stewart.

vwdave

Too much coolant flow can cause overheat issues.