FyreLance

What does everyone think would be the best for the money?

Dual Alpine Type-R 12's

Dual Adire Shiva 12's

Single Adire Brahma 12

Single IDMAX 12

SPL and SQ of equal importance!

stuart69427

My Vote WOULD be for an Elemental Designs sub but I'd go with a Brahma since ED isn't on your list what a shame

My E12A rocks. Now only If I can get a amp for it thats worthy.

9177

cool someone else who has an ed sub. I have a 12A also, getting ready to put it in a 1.5 cu ft ported box. got the glasing done now I need to build the port.

On your list I would look at the brahma or the ID max. both are very good and very capable subs. what kindda power are you willing to give? also are you running for midbass? and what kind of box?

stuart69427

I have had mine out of my car for 5 days now and I'm having withdrawls But I'm getting ready for a REAL amprrack and box. I had my amps mounted to a loose particle board and my sub in a Wal-Mart 1.25cu box I had lying around. I'm surprised the sub didn't blow the box apart.

I'm thinking about ordering either a Stealthbox or a Convertible Flush Box from subthumb.com

I've had the sub for like 9 months and I still haven't built a bow, so I think I should buy one cuase obvioulsy the time to build one isn't happening anytime soon.

I also am thinking about the rear wall mount amprack if I get the stealthbox. But I think I'm leaning towrward to the convertable box and having the sub off to one side and mount an amp on the other. I could put my other amp on an inverted spare tire.

spartyon

i said type rs because 1. i have them and 2. i got 2 new for 80 bucks. i havent heard the others so i have no comment on them.

FyreLance

Those who suggest Elemental Designs feel free to comment as well; I'm not limited to my list.

9177

I love the way my e12A sounds. I had it in a 1.1 cu ft box with around 600 watts. It sounded very nice, was very smooth and offers a very full response. While it can be loud it sounds best to me at moderate levels and imo there is no need for tons of power. Most run it with 500-800 watts and are happy with the output.

jjshep

Personally, I gotta go with the Brahma. I got one B12 in a 2.5 cube box tuned to 30 hz, and love it. Two thumbs up and then some to Adire Audio. I only wish more people knew about them, cause to most people, if it aint rockford, kicker, or audiobahn, its crap. If only they knew what was out there.

blyth18md

a say get the shivas..double the displacement double the fun...i mean i love the brahma too...but theres more factors than just which subs you pick....whatever it is PORT them

CAMp3RO

ouch, you're making it way too hard for me to choose. all of those are great choices and you'll be very happy with all of them. make sure you got the power to run em. i have the type-r (would have been a toss up between the shiva's if i knew about em when i bought the sub) and very happy. brahma is just an unbelievable sub, and the IDMAX is a killer one as well.

TrueBlue91RS

Like others before, I picked the Brahma as well since you didn't list Elemental Designs. Arguably the Brahma is a better sub, but not for the value you can get from ED. But I'm biased: I picked up an Elemental Designs e15SP subwoofer (my dream sub!! ) for my system but it was damaged in shipping so I'm forced to deal with FedEx right now instead of planning the install. So pi$$ed off...

Regardless, the quality you get in either of those subs makes them a very worthwhile purchase. They'll still sound excellent at half the power that they're rated for and you don't have to worry about eventually upgrading your system. If you feel the need, swap out the amp for one with more kick and change the enclosure accordingly. Very versatile.

That said, Adire's Shivas are said to be right at the top as far as "best bang for your buck" goes. I personally haven't heard them so I couldn't say one way or the other, but that company certainly has a quality-first attitude. I won't make any friends here by saying it, but I'd steer way from the Alpines. Good subs in their own right, they're just being outclassed these days. If you want the mainstream answer, go with something from JL.

FyreLance

ttt

stuart69427

I get tired of people saying "Dude, you have it full blast and theres NO DISTORTION!"

oh wait, no I don't

or "If you turn that up anymore, I'm going to have a orgasism"

oh wait, that neither...

I can't wait to get a real amp for my E12A

stuart69427

The W6v2 is one mean sub the W7 isn't bad either...

I remember when I was a NewBe and based my opinion of JL on the w0 series that most people had setup wrong in the first place (gain's are not volume controls )

Other than JL or maybe the Type-R's, I'd stay away from mainstream cuase no matter what theres always a time when advertizing will increase the price and you can get a sub that preforms the same, if not better from companies like eD and Adire whos main concern is quality control and customer service!

FyreLance

I might have to start another thread between the winner of this poll and Elemental Designs...

Keep the opinions coming!

Xplicitblitzboi

im surprised no one has mentioned resonant engineering yet, their HC sub is great for SQ and SPL, www.respl.com check it out.
it is just as good if not better than the brahma in my opinion.

TrueBlue91RS

Resonant Engineering is terrific for the high end stuff, but I don't know about their entry level equipment. Also a bit expensive.

Xplicitblitzboi

yes, a bit pricy, but i can get the 1200 watt HC 12 for 350, so thats not too bad. It may be worth it as well to look into treo's higher end equipment as well.

Boomin Boy

treos higher end equipment doesnt have too much SQ to it from my experiences. I have 2 resonant engineering xxx18s waiting to be thrown into my camaro, and i highly recommend them. RE has great prices and customer service. Also their advertised prices are not always the real prices, there are often unadvertised sales that can only be found out when you call them directly.

Out of the choices on your poll i would choose the Brahma. Mainly because i have a lot of experience with Adire products and have been impressed every time. Also it requires such a small box you can be very creative with the install. The IDMAX is also a very capable sub but i dont have any experience with it yet so i cant comment.

FyreLance

Looks like the Brahma is dominating!


Couple me an amp to that sub. JBL methinks?

Boomin Boy

the JBL 1200 is a great amp for the money
you could also look into products from:

autotek
hifonics
orion (a bit pricey but excellent quality)
zapco

those are just a couple of my favourites

FyreLance

The JBL 1200.1 is exactly what I had in mind actually.

Think that amp would be okay for 2 Brahmas?

9177

Run your box a little bit bigger and you'll be fine.

Boomin Boy

ya if you go to http://www.adireaudio.com and email dan wiggins he will design a good box for you that fits your needs. he's the owner, and an excellent guy to deal with