Spark Adv not matching Spark table

Subscribe
Mar 19, 2009 | 11:59 AM
  #1  
I datalogged today using Datamaster and during a WOT run I noticed that my spark advance only reads 32.7 deg at WOT at any rpm above 3000 but I have 35.86 deg in the main table. Why is it doing this? My base timing is set to 12deg. My PE spark table is zeroed out and I am using the main spark table for all timing. $8d 7730 saujpv4. Thanks in "advance"

Spark Adv not matching Spark table-table.jpg  

Reply 0
Mar 19, 2009 | 07:46 PM
  #2  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
anybody?
Reply 0
Mar 20, 2009 | 08:28 AM
  #3  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
Any takers? Could it be that knock is detected and no allowing it to go to 36deg?
Reply 0
Mar 20, 2009 | 09:08 AM
  #4  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
Check the table bias value and the temperature compensation.
Could be one of those or knock like you said.
Reply 0
Mar 20, 2009 | 12:03 PM
  #5  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
does idle and cruise timing show correct?
Reply 0
Mar 20, 2009 | 03:19 PM
  #6  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
Quote: does idle and cruise timing show correct?
The idle sort of matches the SA closed throttle table. It's set at 22.50 and the spark adv fluctuates between 19 and 24deg. The cruise timing shows correct at 45deg at 2800rpm at 50kpa.
Reply 0
Mar 20, 2009 | 03:23 PM
  #7  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
Quote: Check the table bias value and the temperature compensation.
Could be one of those or knock like you said.
The correction bias temp table is set at 20.04deg.
Reply 0
Mar 20, 2009 | 05:42 PM
  #8  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
Quote: Check the table bias value and the temperature compensation.
Could be one of those or knock like you said.
What does the temp compensation table
look like
Reply 0
Mar 20, 2009 | 06:12 PM
  #9  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
I have an SD system and this is the only spark temp correction table I could find unless there's another one that I'm missing.

Spark Adv not matching Spark table-temp.jpg  

Reply 0
Mar 20, 2009 | 07:22 PM
  #10  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
Check your log for any knock detection and spark retard for that knock. It could be false because at your air fuel and that spark advance with your compression/heads, i dont think you'll have any detonation/knock counts.

I use tunerpro rt and when i do a run, i'll have my spark retard function open and read that along with my main timing and see if it matches. Thing is, usually max timing will still be displayed correctly but the retard will show negative spark, which is how much its pulling. May be the same with your datamaster but i'm not sure.

Also, does your engine base timing match whats in the chip for base reference timing? If its not, it may be abit retarded.
Reply 0
Mar 20, 2009 | 07:30 PM
  #11  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
Quote: Check your log for any knock detection and spark retard for that knock. It could be false because at your air fuel and that spark advance with your compression/heads, i dont think you'll have any detonation/knock counts.

I use tunerpro rt and when i do a run, i'll have my spark retard function open and read that along with my main timing and see if it matches. Thing is, usually max timing will still be displayed correctly but the retard will show negative spark, which is how much its pulling. May be the same with your datamaster but i'm not sure.

Also, does your engine base timing match whats in the chip for base reference timing? If its not, it may be abit retarded.
Base timing does match what's on the chip. There is knock at high rpms but I believe it's from the gear drive. The car pulls very strong(I think I've reached that 400rwhp mark )
Reply 0
Mar 20, 2009 | 07:34 PM
  #12  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
Ahhh, probly false knock. There is a table you can limit how much timing is pulled when knock is detected. I turned mine down to like 2 degrees over the 10-15 it was. You could eliminate it if your comfortable doing so. Your tune should be ok. AFR's have good chambers, like i've said i've run lean and mean with alot of timing no problems detected. Your tune should be safe so you can desensitize the knock sensor
Reply 0
Mar 20, 2009 | 08:15 PM
  #13  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
Quote: I have an SD system and this is the only spark temp correction table I could find unless there's another one that I'm missing.
That's the one I was talking about.
With a bias value of 20, and the temp table flattened at 20, you'll have what is in the main table (after warmup, not closed throttle) and without retard happening.
Sounds like it is some kind of retard happening.
I get some retard at odd times without seeing any knock counts too and when not even beating on it. I've always figured it was just getting to the KS frequency threshold or something, not sure how much effect there is before a knock count actually registers.
Reply 0
Mar 20, 2009 | 09:46 PM
  #14  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
Quote: Ahhh, probly false knock. There is a table you can limit how much timing is pulled when knock is detected. I turned mine down to like 2 degrees over the 10-15 it was. You could eliminate it if your comfortable doing so. Your tune should be ok. AFR's have good chambers, like i've said i've run lean and mean with alot of timing no problems detected. Your tune should be safe so you can desensitize the knock sensor
I was thinking false knock also. I've heard of guys putting copper washers or 90deg bends between the knock sensor and the block to act as a filter. I just went ahead and zeroed out the PE knock retard tables. I'd like to get rid of the gear drive but I love that whine! People think I have a supercharger.
Reply 0
Mar 20, 2009 | 09:49 PM
  #15  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
Quote: That's the one I was talking about.
With a bias value of 20, and the temp table flattened at 20, you'll have what is in the main table (after warmup, not closed throttle) and without retard happening.
Sounds like it is some kind of retard happening.
I get some retard at odd times without seeing any knock counts too and when not even beating on it. I've always figured it was just getting to the KS frequency threshold or something, not sure how much effect there is before a knock count actually registers.
I've seen knock counts register with no spark retard and vice versa. It's weird.
Reply 0
Mar 22, 2009 | 03:06 AM
  #16  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
sounds wierd...

If you like post/email *bin + log file and I can take a look.
Reply 0
Mar 22, 2009 | 12:21 PM
  #17  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
Quote: sounds wierd...

If you like post/email *bin + log file and I can take a look.
Here you go.


Reply 0
Mar 22, 2009 | 10:13 PM
  #18  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
Quote: sounds wierd...

If you like post/email *bin + log file and I can take a look.
Were you able to view the files?
Reply 0
Mar 22, 2009 | 11:34 PM
  #19  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
Suggestions:
1.) You have the low octane routine enabled.
Put them back to 00 until you find the actual problem. This may be masking part or all of it.
2.) You have OL idle and CL idle thresholds both set to 00.
If you wish to disable this function just set them low (as they were) so CL idle happens at 500 RPM rising and it will drop into OL if RPM drops below 350 falling.
Those settings effectivly disable the OL idle routine. There is no on/off for it.
You had manual trans selected but I thought you had an auto.Maybe you have a stick??
Reply 0
Mar 23, 2009 | 08:30 AM
  #20  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
Quote: Suggestions:
1.) You have the low octane routine enabled.
Put them back to 00 until you find the actual problem. This may be masking part or all of it.
2.) You have OL idle and CL idle thresholds both set to 00.
If you wish to disable this function just set them low (as they were) so CL idle happens at 500 RPM rising and it will drop into OL if RPM drops below 350 falling.
Those settings effectivly disable the OL idle routine. There is no on/off for it.
You had manual trans selected but I thought you had an auto.Maybe you have a stick??
I have a manual trans. I am running constant open loop, does it matter on the OL CL idle thresholds? I will disable the low octane routine. I am almost positive that the knock is coming from that stupid gear drive.
Reply 0
Mar 23, 2009 | 11:22 AM
  #21  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
The routine runs for idle only, with both at 00 I'm not sure what that will do beside keep conflicting with itself.
I'd say to put them to the 350 and 500 level and use the normal temp enable to keep you in OL all the time.
Reply 0
Mar 23, 2009 | 11:33 AM
  #22  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
Quote: The routine runs for idle only, with both at 00 I'm not sure what that will do beside keep conflicting with itself.
I'd say to put them to the 350 and 500 level and use the normal temp enable to keep you in OL all the time.
What are the names of the tables you're referring to again? I want to make sure I'm changing the right tables.
Reply 0
Mar 23, 2009 | 11:36 AM
  #23  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
Constants at address 992 & 993 IIRC.
Reply 0
Mar 23, 2009 | 11:45 AM
  #24  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
Quote: Constants at address 992 & 993 IIRC.
Ok thanks JP for your help.
Reply 0
Mar 23, 2009 | 01:07 PM
  #25  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
sorry......... my computer cant open .zip files I download from thirdgen???? maybe a known MS vista problem?? (computer is new....)
Reply 0
Mar 23, 2009 | 05:11 PM
  #26  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
same here, i cant download zips here either. Not using vista. SOmeone suggested its a Internet Explorer thing
Reply 0
Mar 23, 2009 | 05:46 PM
  #27  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
Yes, IE issue. Try using FireFox for the downloads. I also prefer it for a browser over IE.

RBob.
Reply 0
Mar 23, 2009 | 05:54 PM
  #28  
Re: Spark Adv not matching Spark table
PM your emails so I can email them to yall.
Reply 0
Subscribe